New XKCD Forums

@patzer you have spent most of D2 tunneled on heury/Seven. Why didn't you react or say anything about Seven's odd opening post ?

@BoomFrog why aren't you pushing moody on me if you think he's scum?

I’m here! Anything interesting happen when I was at work? What do you think about Zen's commentary on patzer above? I think patzer is non-town. I think Seven’s analysis is reasonable as patzer is definitely trying too hard not to ruffle any feathers, by not doing any analysis or having any scum read...

Daily catch up post. Cynical view owes you a couple of Milkbones. awesome.PNG it takes a lot of effort to sort out the middle of my list on signs that don’t mean as much relevance, but on the other hand mechanic analysis is crucial for working of if town!seven is plausible. Which is really the main ...

Daily catch up post. This is an odd question as it seems patently obvious that non-town would not want to resurrect a member of town, unless they’re literally trying to lose. Jimbob’s confusion about this is... odd. I already covered this with somitomi. Why wouldn’t mafia want to resurrect a distrac...

Something came up last night so I wasn't able to work on this. Here are my updated reads, not as thorough as I would like but I need to go out for a few hours. BoomFrog From D1, I still don’t see how Suzaku’s case on The Snide Sniper changed BoomFrog from a scum to a town lean. BoomFrog what is you ...

Morning thought, how was the below "noted" concern not in your notes? like really.PNG If you want I can post my notes to where I left off on D1. Please do. Ok. This is where I was at on Sunday when I made this post . I probably had only copied things from my old posts and hadn’t gotten to...

If you want I can post my notes to where I left off on D1. Please do. Ok. This is where I was at on Sunday when I made this post . I probably had only copied things from my old posts and hadn’t gotten too far with a new reread. BoomFrog Don’t like that Suzaku’s case on The Snide Sniper changed Boom...

@Bessie: Eta on finishing you reads list? If you want I can post my notes to where I left off on D1. Other than that, between being sick and working, I don’t have more than about an hour a night to play, and that’s usually what I spend on my catch up post. Most of my thoughts are in my daily posts....

Catch up post from my last post at the top of page 7. Vote: heury What were your reasons for voting for heury? I know you had him on your scum list, but you never gave a read or reasons why. Pre-post edit: this was answered see below. Oh boo. I was hoping to be in the cult today... Capture 2.PNG As ...

I have nothing I feel like claiming.

I'm going to work back tonight.

Ok. How do you reconcile these remarks with having heury and Snide Sniper at the bottom of your WOO-BOO list? I feel like I have this discussion every single game and I'm kinda surprised you don't remember me saying the same thing in WWZ: It's D1 and I simply don't care if my scumreads make sense a...

Can everyone post if they expect to be on line around deadline?
(Mostly the non US people)

I am leaning on voting for heury. I can vote now but that will place heury at L-2.

@Bessie: When did you figure out the faction flavor connection? Right away or just now when composing an answer to my question, or somewhere in between? Did you find it obvious or confusing? I’ve had this in my mind for a while. The reason that I didn’t answer your question in this post is that whe...

Catch up post. I'm definitely not going to not try to read you, don't worry. I'm just stating for the record that I find it hard to do so. If you have any questions that would help you read me, you can ask. After all I am a reactive player. On the use of "we" being a tell or not - I absolu...

@patzer and @Bessie: My real question I was trying to ask indirectly was, which scum group do you think has which flavor? How do you match up mafia, cult and survivor to Madge's Maniacs, Sabrar's Socialites and ??? ? I think this is Sabrar’s group, and that the bribe is this refers to the mafia’s n...

Quick request for everyone, please don’t change the text for the spoiler tags. On my computer I don’t see anything that indicates the spoiler (I do see a little arrow on my phone). This is what somitomi’s spoiler looks like to me:

Sorry I was tired last night and didn’t make my daily catch up post. As I said, exactly on meta as far as I can recall :) And a null-tell, as I'm sure I've seen you do the same as scum. Good point about somi, though. Maybe just that his individual posts are shorter, or maybe my subconscience is sayi...

I only had a few hours sleep last night so here’s my daily catch up post; reads and analysis will be this weekend. am I full of BS? Unfortunately this question is not directed at me. :P I just realized that my new larp character is essentially my BoomFrog persona. I'm so much more excited. Nothing g...

I'm currently undecided of Boomfrog is scum taking advantage of my slightly scummy appearance right now, or if this is Boomfrog who thinks they laid a trap and actually caught a scum. Thinking more about it, the latter seems more likely. Somi, what is your opinion of me right now? Why do you think ...

Has Boomfrog ever done a gambit as mafia? I've only ever seen them do it as town. Why is it that my joke vote almost always becomes my end day d1 vote? I seem to remember Boomfrog has pulled a gambit as mafia, let me close my helicopter record and check my mafia notes... I checked my game spreadshe...

I’m here. Like usual, I don’t play during work hours (California). @jimbobmacdoodle and @heuristically_alone, please get avatars. @The Snide Sniper, welcome to the mafia group! @patzer, I remember you playing mafia but not of playing with you. Very happy to have you sign up! Anyway, enough of this m...

madge wrote: ↑Wed Sep 15, 2021 2:56 am See my edit. I'm the mod so I get to edit stuff and be above the law

Well I guess this is a bastard game.

madge wrote: ↑Wed Sep 15, 2021 2:39 am That's hammer! Rebirth was Mod's Favoured Pet and has been made the official theme

??
With 10 alive it takes 6 to eliminate.

Congrats Heury and Jimbob!