New XKCD Forums

Personally I don't like the mod modifying a role without a very good reason or putting in a new one completely. For me it breaks the concept of Secret Santa where everyone knows that their submitted role is present. I like the idea of mod putting in a role, that way no one can be sure if the role th...

Interest List (/in?):
1. moody7277
2. bessie
3. heury
4. Boomfrog
5. Madge
6.
7. osieorb18
9.
10.


Replacements
1. Sabrar
√2.
2.
3.
π.

Congrats to town, I apologize for my poor play. For some reason I simply couldn't find the drive in me to participate appropriately.

Who do you think would actually defend Jedi with that 'content'?

I will be also basically mod-confirmed, though not on D2 by current standings.

Yes and you could vote Jedi. I'm pretty sure I will give more info than him on later days as well.

Teaches me not to sign up to a game with max post count limitations.

I can go MathBlade, maybe Wisp as well. Not sure we will have 6

I think it's 4 on me, 5 on Jedi, Michelle, Seven, Suzaku, Wisp voting off-wagon.

FTR I'm not going to claim my role.

Anesthesia wore off in the middle of my treatment, what fun...

My vote stays for now but I'm open to yeet Seven. Or Mathblade for that matter.

Sab has had some weird tonal jumps in regards to certain players, like when Morgan talked about Seven's read on me and he went out of his way too make 4 points on the subject. It just felt out of place If you're talking about this , the second part was a reply to Seven who asked me to comment on hi...

@everyone if Jedi flips mafia what's happening, if Jedi flips town what's happening? Where do you look next in both of these worlds? This is premature as a) we might not yeet Jedi, b) there will probably be an NK which would give info and c) we might have results after tonight. If Jedi flips town, ...

And what do you make of it in terms of his alignment? Nothing. It's bad idea, it doesn't make Wisp scum. People can change their minds, but I don't see how anyone could believe Wisp was joking about the town-core post. Why? People do gambits all the time, not that I'm a big fan. So is it more impor...

This shouldn't happen i mean thoughts about the game shouldn't be posted elsewhere than this thread It was a tradition on the old xkcd site to have a forum where spectators could speculate about the game, also where players could post their true thoughts/vent their frustrations/etc. It is a gentlem...

You can iso Jedi (forum allows sort by author) and you will see it quickly for yourself..

EBWOP: before they posted

Why do you think Wake will never get traction before the posted anything relevant?

The case doesn't do anything for me. If anything, your case looks spun to come to a pre-determined conclusion. Congratulations, you have successfully encapsulated Seven's usual mo (and it's NAI). - Reason 1: could be coming from scum for reasons stated. have seen it from town as well more than a fe...

Interesting. SuperJedi is unhelpful, but in your opinion, is it in a malicious way, and does that make SuperJedi scum? Why not vote MathBlade, who is the only other player on whom you actually have firm scum lean? I can't determine maliciousness and it doesn't make them scum necessarily. But they h...

This is standard Jedi play and pressure isn't going to change it. I'm surprised none of the xkcd players have pointed this out. SuperJedi's name looked familiar so I checked Smashboards and couldn't find them. I had no recollection of playing with them on xkcd. If this is their standard playstyle t...

Vote: SuperJedi

They are here, they are ignoring questions/requests, they show no desire to help.

Wisp : I'm seeing townie aggression and confidence, contemplating avenues that scum would less likely to do. His confusion wrt moody in Halloween seems genuine and would indicate that he really re-read the game with the purpose of solving moody. Although some posts ping me as possible power wolfing...

Welcome Seven! So ideally these next few players should have posted more... patzer : nothing to report here, a single post with 'content' but it only contains a neutral read and some 'more later'-s. At least she's aware that she should be contributing more, but this is still lurking. SuperJedi : fir...

bessie : asks good questions and interacts with multiple players but that is standard for her and therefore NAI (maybe she would earn half a point on moody's scale, I don't know). However early aggression (or snarkyness or whatever you want to call it) is in my opinion more often coming from town a...