Pick Your Poison Mafia (Day 2)

[JC_DADDY25]

Doctor. This is why you shouldn't post at 455 am

Which doctor?

[Makhaira]

fuck it fine

Unvote: Bessie
Vote: Wam

[Wam]

Doctor. This is why you shouldn't post at 455 am

Which doctor?

Normal

[boomfrog]

just in case

I think we hammered but just in case you should vote wam.

[Seven]

Boom scum. Probably with moody and TBD. Farewell guys

agree

[Makhaira]

whoa super ninjad

is this the "accidental" hammer thing again

lmaooooo no I wasnt even trying to hammer I get the deja vu tho

[fontisian]

I'm the sodding Town cop. Have fun guys.

I don't buy you the "town" part

[Makhaira]

why is wam claiming cop then doc wtf

[AdumbroDeus]

Time! No more votes

[EGW]

Votecount Final

1. Boomfrog
2. Wam: Bessie, JC, Seven, Boomfrog, Fonti, Moodie, Mak
3. Swiss
4. Mak
5. Fred
6. Madge
7. Seven: Swiss
8. moody: Fred, Sabrar, Madge
9. JC
10. Fonti
11. bessie: Wam
12. Sabrar

Not voting:
No one

Important Links:
Game links and Vote Counts

Notes:
N/A

With 12 players, it takes 7 votes to eliminate.
The deadline for Day 1 is Thursday 7th, at 11:59PM EST

[AdumbroDeus]

Day End

Wam has been Eliminated! They are town doctor


Night 1 Begins the deadline for N1 is Sunday December 10th at 11:59PM EST

[AdumbroDeus]

laserguy replaces moody!

[AdumbroDeus]

Day 2 Begins!

Laserguy has been Eliminated! They are town weak doctor
Freddino has been eliminated, they are vanilla town
Mak has been eliminated! They are vanilla town



Votecount 2.1

1. Boomfrog
2. Swiss
3. Madge
4. Seven
5. JC
6. Fonti
7. bessie
8. Sabrar

Not voting:
Everyone

Important Links:
Game links and Vote Counts

Notes:
N/A

With 8 players, it takes 5 votes to eliminate.


The deadline for Day 2 is Friday December 15th at 11:59PM EST

[madge]

wait WHAT

[madge]

okay so Laserguy was once moody. 4 dead town. 3 scum in 8.

i have a bunch of thoughts but i don't want to lay it out yet. keen to see other reactions

[Seven]

Madge that pfp IS nice. I couldn't see it fully on mobile before.

Whichever one of you killed Fred (side eye at bessie) needs to sit in timeout.

I like how scum picked the same roles I picked when I played. Too funny, you really are the xkcd version of me.

[madge]

i have a scum pick already but i will do some more reading tonight (about to go on a site visit)

[madge]

ooo i like your anime mewtwo

[fontisian]

bessie:

Spoiler (Show/Hide)

D0
post 1: Thinks Janitored flips would be town, short bios of the players, found my nightmare game, some extracurricular discussion
post 2: disagrees with Swiss about whether D0 should have scumhunting, piqued about Swiss asking about the replacement, votes rolecop
post 3: answer to BF: would pick cop and doc for town as scum
post 4: apology for not answering him earlier
post 5: further discussion re replacement, bios supposed to be NAI, didn't realize scum get to pick 3 perqs, decides on Vig for 3rd

As I understand the concept, this post has a townslip in it. Did not vote for second scum perq, but since that got hammered quickly, she may not have had an opportunity

D1
post 6: Says rolecop will be moot due to powerclaims, upset by Seven's interpretation of her reading of the setup, answers Sabrar about cop+Doc, says would take too long to be useful to town, suspicious of passive Fred, doesn't like Swiss's vote
post 7: Seven suspiciously ignorant of roles
post 8: "Doth protest too much"
post 9: explanation of post 8, wants Fred to explain his read of her and wam
post 10: still asking Fred about his read of her, not impressed with Seven, answering Seven's concern about her Janitor explanation, uses Foses to keep vote serious
post 11: D1 crucial to solve, still has nebulous curiosity about Swiss's replacement ask, other jabs about her playstyle by Swiss, wants Mak to expand read on Fred.

This last post is another way bessie and Madge are opposites. I think I found who she's tunnelling this game. Other content looks comfortably town. Final score +4

Moody/Laser had to have died because they targeted scum.

Moody's strongest townread was bessie. However, that was midday and Moody voted for Bessie to self-pres before the end of the day. The other two town reads were me and boom, again stated at midday. I don't see any updated reads, and I don't know if Moody or Laser would have been the one to pick their target, which makes any analysis from them dying really useless.

I'm going to take it to mean someone who was being townread is scum, which, like, that was already an easy assumption to make.

For future games, if you are weak doc, please say something before eod make your target easier to figure out.

[fontisian]

We are in Mylo. We have a vig who can save us if we fuck up, as long as they do not hit the vengeful mafia. Vengeful scum can quick hammer if we are not careful, so be careful with your votes.

Zen, can you talk about what you were trying to do at eod? Talk about the swap from Bessie back to Wam in particular, please.

[Sabrar]

LaserGuy replaced in at the worst possible moment as now we have no idea who he targeted.
The whole situation would be hilarious except it's sad. Time to reread.

[fontisian]

JC, would you mind talk about your reads and thoughts, which as much detail as possible?

[Seven]

So we have Boom and Fonti as scum.

Me, Sabrar, and Swiss are town.

So hopefully vig is in one of the other three for PoE sake. I'll have to catch up on the last few pages of EoD yesterday to see who I think is the third. My initial impression is that it's Madge.

[Seven]

i feel more strongly about getting a yeet today than i do about moody vs wam, so willing to change. but i am only around for another 45 minutes or so

This is kind of townie. I think scum probably had day copped Wam hence Boom's sudden strong push, yet Madge is nonchalant about which of the two to yeet.

[Seven]

I ask, because I only play from my phone so the avatars don't even show up on the side. They are small and in the top left corner of every post. Maybe it's a different phone, but I still don't understand how you're blaming the avatars for anything.

Especially when that part is in the middle of his posts, so it's not like you're going to get it confused with someone else's.

Holy shit, this is amazing.