New XKCD Forums

When I was saying 2 shot RB and godfather were my top picks to give scum, that was my initial position just in the context of "which scum roles do I think are the least threatening in a vacuum not knowing what town roles that scum selected I'm not ignoring the context, the whole issue here is ...

@JC: I would still like you to answer this.

Sabrar what is your read on fonti? I like how they constantly reevaluated the roles D0. I don't agree with some of their opinion but they gave reasonable explanation. I've especially like this fresh perspective. D1 they are expressing an opinion on a bunch of players (which again I like) but their ...

@boomfrog: here you are asking moody to speculate on why the setup has both doc and weak doc as an option. moody misinterprets the question here. what was the purpose of the question and why did you not follow-up like you have with others?

Yeah that should work. Maybe make the link a little bit bigger so we can click it more easily. Thanks!

@Swiss: please next time just link to the posts instead of quoting the whole thing. It makes it so much more readable.

Having more experience playing with Madge, I pay attention to her more than a newer player I'm still trying to figure out. This implies that you haven't noticed the vote at all. Also, with as much hyperbole as I put down about the role, I didn't really sense there was much of a push for the role. T...

@moody: fonti voted for Janitor here and unvoted here. Between the two posts you have FoS-d madge for just leaning towards Janitor but you didn't acknowledge fonti's vote. You also posted immediately after fonti's unvote and still haven't mentioned them neither at that time, nor later. Why?

JC_DADDY25 wrote: ↑Thu Nov 30, 2023 2:40 pm Well, the rolecop gives the roleblocker an advantage they didn't have before, in that now they don't have to use it blindly. There is probably 2 or 3 mafia on that vote.

How does the second sentence follow logically from the first? It was not at all assured that scum would get RB as well.

Oh, so you don't like playing with me? I don't think that reflects poorly on you. We all have people that grind our gears. Is my play this game similar to AI in your view? - I don't enjoy playing with you in the sense that I feel it diminishes my winchances. I've clashed with you enough times when ...

Yes I have. For the Doctor to protect the Cop, the cop would need to claim which I’m sure will happen early anyway especially if it is Madge. This gives mafia a better chance of hitting the Doctor with a kill, role cop, or block. The Cop won’t be useful until they have at least two, maybe three res...

Sabrar not casting a single vote in the role voting phase really, really bothers me, scumlean tbh Here we go again. I know it's not a popular opinion but I have explained multiple times in the past that the act of voting is not relevant until the last phase of a day. So you can be the tenth person ...

JC_DADDY25 wrote: ↑Sat Dec 02, 2023 4:44 pmActually, who is using the GoJoe thread in this game?

Why don't you just check who posted there? Also, why is it relevant?

No, I don't know Seven outside of the game.

No. It's personal and doesn't reflect well on me.

Swiss wrote: ↑Sat Dec 02, 2023 10:55 am Sabrar if you had to Lynch right now who would it be and why

Seven but I would prefer not to tell why.

Sabrar concluding me most likely scum based on my content related to role selection does not track at all with his stated premises and assumptions about how scum would interect with setup knowledge. Like if anything my ignorance of the clickability of the roles should be a point in my favor unless ...

Late answers: - as Mafia I would have given Town Vig, weak Doc and Masoniser. Vig is probably the least disruptive to Mafia, and the combination of Cop+Doc is scary. However Cop is already scary on its own after 2 checks and they are likely to get at least that many as GF or RB is not assured for sc...

PYP

Spoiler (Show/Hide)

Town!me is complaining about the second hammer and the fact that he planned to publish some juicy analysis today.

That is true but if GF gets accepted into town-core because of their ability then they will make finding the rest harder in the first place.

Smooth dodge. Mid-long. Why are you answering your own question? Observation 1 Seven hammers Rolecop at the end of a lengthy post. madge unvotes Rolecop 1 minute later, also at the end of a lengthy post. Both contents organically follow from questions addressed to them, note that one of the questio...

Why did you not speculate on what mafia would select for town PRs as the foundation of your analysis? Because I haven't made an analysis yet? I think excluding Janitor is trivial and the rest is situational as described previously. @ madge : could you please describe with your own words what the Ja...

PYP

Spoiler (Show/Hide)

town!me would be hard sulking about the fact that there is noone to talk to and that several topics are banned, killing the discussion.

1st post Flips are important enough that I'm going to FoS anyone who votes for it. I was in a game without flips, and town got steamrolled. For reference this was in response to Freddino's question why Janitor is bad. Given moody's previous experience with the mechanic the reply makes sense and the...

I'm happy to be of service.

Why moody? Do you want my opinion now, based on 3 short posts with no real interaction with anyone or is that expectation for the future?