New XKCD Forums

I doubt there is any resurrection ability other than the phoenix, but we'll see... I'm of course somewhat skeptical of your arguments but I do see your point. Will do it if others agree with you.

Going to update my reads list first since I was in the middle of writing this out. Bessie: sensible strategy to try to generate more information by counterwagon, but it does raise the question of exactly who would take the blame for such a thing... if Heury flips scum (as we all expect) it would nat...

Wam wrote: ↑Wed Oct 13, 2021 9:07 am I would claim your role if I was you, if claiming would help town.

If I would get yeeted otherwise, it'd help town.

If I had any other way out of it, it'd be beneficial for me to refrain from claiming... but I don't know if I do

Well fuck. Wondering if I should let people know my role yet- if you yeet me I won't get the chance to give out potentially useful information, so I'll need to say soon.

Emphasis added by me (apparently we can't do color anymore?). Are you... having trouble keeping your thoughts straight? This is not the first time you've contradicted yourself in a single post. Do you frequently edit your posts as you write them and rethink them? Oh my god you’re right I didn’t edi...

@patzer: https://ramenchef.net/nxf/viewtopic.php?p=8321&sid=08e68c4b558fada8421de08830b815d3#p8321 Please answer. These question may seem superfluous but they are important for me to understand your mental state. I hadn't recalled you saying that before- thank you. This post you'd linked to Unl...

I take it cult recruitment is standard for games with cults in them then.
So yeah, it’s almost certainly going to be the case here.

I doubt multiple people will have conversion ability but who knows.

It's not patzer's first game ever (she's played before, albeit a while back - this was also discussed by her previously, I believe). Why did you think it was? I figured she was an OTTer who was just now dipping her toe into mafia instead of being a mafiOTTer all along like us. bessie already brough...

patzer - we've been discussing a cult the entire game, since the very first game post in the thread, in fact. It's been discussed in mod posts, and in questions to the mod. I'm assuming you know what a cult is in terms of Mafia... Ah right, I didn’t know it was confirmed the cult had recruitment ab...

@patzer: My previous question was important, please answer it. Why did you think zombie flavor made sense for the cult when we already know the cult's flavor? Where did you find the cult’s flavour? I don’t remember it being announced. This is kind of important as it may affect my judgment; thank yo...

Seven wrote: ↑Mon Oct 11, 2021 4:28 pm

patzer wrote: ↑Mon Oct 11, 2021 12:19 pm just noticed I hadn't voted yet.

Vote: Seven

What is this based on?

Pretty much the whole conversation so far. I can't envisage any feasible scenario in which you are currently town- but if you'd like to try to convince me of why you got resurrected, I'd like to hear it.

strapped (add P)

This discussion was already had between two other players earlier in the thread - see somitomi versus moody . By rezzing town, and then town voting them off again, mafia end up potentially gaining 2 NKs without any town gain (aside from the flip). If Mafia have an unlimited rez action, this doesn't...

Growing increasingly confused by jimbob’s readings wrt me and my questions now. Then, her actual analysis is written not about "heury is town" etc but rather "heury was rezzed by town"? Yet a conclusion of "heury is town" is then ruled out. I don't know what to make of ...

@patzer (and others who find it useful), I don't know what exactly you're currently doing, but I go through everybody's posts by going to the bottom of this thread, and using the order by author option. This orders the thread by author, in time order, so you can just jump to the starting point of t...

727

at MLP convention rn but it’s half an hour before events start so here we go Because she hasn’t posted an opinion on anyone except heury since her reads list on 9/30/21, nine days ago, which she claimed was tentative because she didn’t have much to go on. Her D2 content is a reposting of the same li...

@patzer, I reread your earlier post and realised that I'd missed your mafia case somehow (got too distracted by other bits for some reason). (I would still like to know why you didn't answer me though...). Re mafia with resurrection ability, it’s possible but feels incredibly overpowered. Not sure ...

jimbobmacdoodle wrote: ↑Fri Oct 08, 2021 11:49 am @patzer - cult!heury is almost ruled out by mod confirmation that dead players don't show up in the cult numbers. Did you miss this? Also, what about scum with resurrection power?

Oh that changes things. Where was that mod post? I don’t remember it.

Well, that wasn’t what I expected. The obvious question now is who resurrected Heury? Hypothesis 1: Heury is town. Who would have brought him back? No reason for anyone from town to do so. If we’ve got a resurrectionist surely they’d go for Suzaku absent any more information given our qualms about H...

pectorals (A/E -> P)

Well this is annoying. I was hoping we'd get some new information in finding out about who heury was, but evidently not.

I'll try to analyse what I think of everyone now in the morning.

locaters (add R)