New XKCD Forums

Osie well played you convinced me in day 1 the worst needs time and that was my fault. He was pure scum and I let myself fooled I knew Bessie can't be scum and I was paranoid of Madge. That was another mistake i made I came to the truth and i am sure a player who knows me would understand me. My la...

WMU is excellent, and terrifies me greatly.

I think -- if this player list was more familiar with WMU and we could have gotten away with it without it being really obvious that one of us did it -- wmu would have been n1'd. I wasn't expecting to need to let bessie live past n1, and then also wasn't expecting to n2 her. she is pretty scary.

THE CATGIRL CLUTCH!! That was my role! When I saw that result I was like "oh my god the catgirl actually did something!" Good game, truly. Frankly, it's hilarious that the catgirl actually did something meaningful. I think your (paraphrasing) "I thought I'd caught Bessie's killer but...

me!!

rat?

Good game all! Thanks for modding wam and seven <3

I think I can see scum!Wmu and I think her partner might be Madge. My biggest fear going into today is that the scumteam is wmu/snide but like... Osie just doesn't really make sense as scum with anyone who's left alive. I guess if this is red there's a decent chance I'll be night killed, so good luc...

I'm not really making heads or tails of it either atm

prev. suggestion of massclaim may not have been all that prudent; as osie pointed out this setup is probably not mechsolvable

I have literally been scumhunting all game. Like all I have been doing is pressing people asking questions discussing things and giving my reads. This is how I scumhunt. Suspect me if you need to but "hasn't scumhunted all game" is patently false - ive been scumhunting for the entire game.

OKAY FULLCLAIM I promise 100000% that there is nothing secret, I have kept nothing from you. I'm a compulsive visitor. I must visit someone in the night and either they're told I visited them, or in the case of the NK, the whole thread is told I visited the NK target in bold at day start. N1 Osie N...

My votes are on WMU and the worst. I'm not too stressed yet, but your solve isn't 2/2. we're pretty close to the wire, and town voting incorrectly is going to cost us the game. Not saying you need to bend your reads because I tell you to - ive just found you a bit inscrutable this game and I happen...

otherwise roughly
Osie > Madge > wmu > snide
I'd prefer going before or after wmu but can be whenever

Its been a minute since ive been alive in ELo so I fully intend to take the time to solve this properly. I'd fairly strongly encourage massclaiming first.

If anyone can confirm or deny the catgirl thing they should probs claim first

The Snide Sniper wrote: ↑Sun Feb 13, 2022 9:08 pm By the way, given that bessie saw madge visit osie N2 and he very clearly isn't dead, I think we can put her down as "unlikely". My votes are on WMU and the worst.

(Also, does xylo mean the same thing as elo?)

Yeah, XyLo = something-or-lose; ELo = eliminate correctly or lose.

I feel like this setup is going to be hilarious once all is revealed

worst this time!
somi?

Rat?

No. And I am me!

heury?

xX_WakeMeUp1337_Xx wrote: ↑Thu Feb 10, 2022 6:17 am Cats are not sucking our energy btw, they give us with their purr comfort and peace of mind.

Agreed nothing more recharging than snuggling a lil purring ball of fur.

I'm kinda lukewarm on slips as well but I think this one belies a pretty malicious mindset!

Heury's posting talks about boomfrog like he knows he's flipped town but then forgets about moody being flipped town. Dont really care if it's sincere mistake or trying to trick us - we'll never know. Someone who's subconsciously aware of who was the scum nightkill but not aware of who was the town ...

is no1 around or is no1 seeing heury's perspective slip

osieorb18 wrote: ↑Wed Feb 09, 2022 4:24 pm

Mm this is by no means comprehensive
I dont really have anything to add to the rest of your responss to you/bessie I'm just kinda waiting for something else to happen

Vote Madge If the most important thing you noticed is the dog vs cat choice and you didn't even noticed I choose cats, while you are not shocked for the town read I received from the worst who would gladly kill me D1, then I'm thinking your intention is not to solve this game. There are also other ...