New XKCD Forums

He did not out MathBlade. MathBlade outed himself, and then counterclaimed. This is a fairly tiny point of order but Mathb wouldn't have outed if not for the fakeclaim. I'm not surprised you aren't reading my posts, but no, MathBlade outed of his own free will, completely independent of the fakecla...

Seven you've already had me out and outed a roleblocker. Stop rolefishing pls, I think you're town and your formidable ability with a claim fishing rod isnt helping. He did not out MathBlade. MathBlade outed himself, and then counterclaimed. This is a fairly tiny point of order but Mathb wouldn't h...

That's fine by me. I'm disinterested in having moody claim, and disinterested in explaining why rn. I can't give you anything that'll make him easier to read.

If you have a read on his day play though that would help a lot.

live footage of seven https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/913843174957547542/915126168045375568/seven.png I think I'm someone who should be in most peoples potential scum pool atm, but I think I'm a fairly poor elimination today simply on the basis that I should be able to get a clear tonight. :P

Madge literally taking the words out of my mouth. Figuratively.

Osie designs setups very deliberately so that they can't be solved via claims alone. That means there's value in information being collected by roles, but also a very high probability that scum have some way to use knowledge of roles against players - I'd rather kick claiming as much as possible dow...

Seven you've already had me out and outed a roleblocker. Stop rolefishing pls, I think you're town and your formidable ability with a claim fishing rod isnt helping.

Welcome, Märklin. sorry: vote: Morgan hadn't caught up. I'm interested in voting moody Bad vote imho. Moody is a lot Townie than most of the game. I can see it kinda? I don't feel confident on Moody but I suddenly strongly feel that Seven is town and want to see how that adventure goes. Can you thro...

sorry:
vote: Morgan
hadn't caught up.

I'm interested in voting moody

@moody please address this . So you've pulled this stunt in a lot of games, exactly one of which I was in for any length of time. Still not impressed. Townies lying about power results leads to confusion, and confusion aids scum. That makes no sense. exCUSE me how dare you accuse someone other than...

Morgan, can you talk through why you seem to be approaching this conversation from a pov where Seven is town but you're also not particularly motivsted to defend him or explain the read? Any way I try to spin this, it looks like you're approaching this from a scum perspective. Doesn't really tell me...

@bessie i don't think Morgan is interested in solving the game. When they do give opinions, I'm not convinced that they're actually saying stuff that they believe is true. Seven is an easy player to have an opinion on right now. I was think the way Morgan is remaining as noncommittal is a very safe ...

cracking me up

vote: Morgan (sorry for the spoilers)

@bessie MBs been saying random stuff all game that doesn't seem to align with the actual game we're playing, it's a bit dizzying to deal with tbh. And from a glance it seems to be all about my claim. @worst, I posted my reads and what not a bit ago. As well as reads in that post. your reads haven't...

Providing extensive meta of handling claims immaturely seems like a glorious way to make a plist like you, lol. Can your do something to help the game? Please? Mathb's post is worth a read. Its laid out well and easier to digest than you'd think. It also contains actual opinions on things happening ...

Vote: Seven vote: Seven Fine, Seven elim is probably happening. I’m gonna reread him when I get a chance, hopefully tonight after work. Can anyone who knows how Seven plays talk about how he might be mafia *outside* of the fakeclaim? I really don’t care to read too much into something that had virt...

I feel like Madge's gaspers are as flabbered as mine are. She sounds legitimately flabbergasted. I know its like, more tonal reasoning for a read, but I think that's town indicative.

Just to be clear: I can get a reasonably solid alignment check on Jedi tonight.

Seven is a solid lim, policy or not I think they're kinda scummy? They're firmly poe!

Seven wrote: ↑Fri Nov 26, 2021 6:09 pm the worst visited wisp btw

this isn't implicit fam lol its pretty explicit!
how did you ever expect this to shake out differently? what was going through your head when you made the decision to post this?

Just ftr I think if mathblade hadn't counterclaimed seven would have proceeded quite differently so my vote is there in spirit as well I was just being nice to lull seven into a false sense of safety Actually [v]Seven[/v] one scum in {seven, mathblade} edit for vote (hope this is ok, mindful of how ...

not sure why you would Because you lied about having a result on the worst? and? (also I didn't for the record) ok u literally did I'm anti "lim all liars" as a policy (its good as like, a holistic meta ploy to correct a poor play across several years; but it's also unlikely to win games ...

Moody can you rewrite this first sentence using no pronouns? Who knew what was coming? Wisp was fairly sure he was going to be the NK. In my wild ass guess I figure the reason that Wisp's premonition, for lack of a better word, turned out to be true was that the killers were working from the same b...

Moody can you rewrite this first sentence using no pronouns? Who knew what was coming? Wisp was fairly sure he was going to be the NK. In my wild ass guess I figure the reason that Wisp's premonition, for lack of a better word, turned out to be true was that the killers were working from the same b...

CLAIM RELATED NOTES: the worst visited wisp (claimed by Seven, recanted???) mathblade blocked the worst (claimed by mathblade, confirmed?) the worst doesn't have a targeting role (claimed by the worst) can confirm no. 2 & 3 via my role I'm not like, 100% sure I was blocked (it may have failed d...

Quick town/scum, will likely revise as the day progresses: moody bessie madge Wake Wam worst morgan seven math suzaku I'd guess there's scum in worst/seven/math (currently hoping not worst but can't rule it out) would you be willing to switch bessie & Madge, and then math & seven? just for ...