New XKCD Forums

Still leaning toward the killers in [Mak, somi] and last human in [moody, bessie]

Won't be around basically at all today.
Vote: Makhaira

System.out.println(" System.out.println(" Nope, I was right on Seven. But if Bessie wants they can do an apology dance for me and boom :p That's essentially a similar critique of Moody's play that I made last day phase. I don't put much stock in wagonomics without understanding intent beh...

System.out.println(" Wagons so far: D1 Seven - 4 - Bessie, EGW , Heury , Somi Moody - 2 - Makhaira, Zeniba Zeniba - 6 - Boomfrog , Seven , Adum, Moody, LaserGuy, Gluelock Not voting: JC Seven - 5 - Bessie, EGW , Heury, Somi, Moody EGW - 3 - Gluelock , LaserGuy, Adum Moody - 2 - Makhaira, Zenib...

Wagons so far: D1 Seven - 4 - Bessie, EGW , Heury , Somi Moody - 2 - Makhaira, Zeniba Zeniba - 6 - Boomfrog , Seven , Adum, Moody, LaserGuy, Gluelock Not voting: JC Seven - 5 - Bessie, EGW , Heury, Somi, Moody EGW - 3 - Gluelock , LaserGuy, Adum Moody - 2 - Makhaira, Zeniba JC_Daddy - 2 - Seven , Bo...

The logic of the game seems to be pointing to humans having strong, obviously townie powers [cop, doc] Actual town seems to have more middleweight-to-weak powers [bodyguard, gunsmith, neighborizer] Killer's powers may be outliers in some other way. Of claimed roles we have: JoAT (Laser) Absorber (Ad...

From where I'm sitting it looks like we have:

bessie - Human
One or both of somi/Mak - Killing scum

System.out.println(" Well fuck me I was completely wrong this game needs a full reread jfc thankfully im not traveling this week so I can do a dive Adum do you know if the neighborhood survives the death of the neighborizor? Did you have any chance to chat with seven last night? also did you g...

Woof. I also think Seven was an interesting choice for a kill. I believe we have at least two remaining scum. I am not afraid of Seven. You should be. Seven ate Nine. :mrgreen: And why did Seven eat Nine? Because you're supposed to be three squared meals a day How does Gluelock's flip affect the re...

System.out.println(" Actually, what did you and Seven talk about last night Laser ? "); Not much. Looks something like this: Seven - Surprised that Glue flipped Town. Laser - They were pretty townie for most of the game, but yeah, it was a terrible mistake. Seven - What night action are y...

System.out.println(" Honestly perplexed by the seven kill, they were almost lynched twice AND their powers weren't that useful. Either we're dealing with a situation that scum thought all the powers that were stronger were scum of the same faction or protected in some form (as I said I'm of th...

moody7277 wrote: ↑Tue Oct 24, 2023 11:50 am

AdumbroDeus wrote: ↑Tue Oct 24, 2023 4:29 am System.out.println("

Hey @moody, got results?

");

Only thing I saw was somi visit you.

Who else did you target? There's few enough of us your negative results could be useful.

System.out.println(" seven neighborized me which means Somi's chat cop is wasted, I genuinely don't understand why seven world do that but I find the fact that somi is still alive... Interesting. Either way, Seven's death means that we're left with Laser being able to figure out EGW was the Do...

Halloween

Spoiler (Show/Hide)

Don't really have much to say right now. Just feels like it will be seen as suspicious in some circles if I don't post here.

From these posts, it looks like he thought EGW was the killer not the doctor. Seven is the one who knew EGW was the doctor. Yes, I was tracking a player I thought was scum. And after you realized they were a loud doctor why did that not change That wasn't clear. George may have been the killer who ...

Moody is scum. His initial points on Bessie were too gracious, and his sudden change of read seemed disingenuous. Zeniba pushing him for seeming no solid reason, also makes the push make sense as informed. I'm going to re-read but at the moment that throws a kink in my Zen read. I admit I'm wrong o...

N1: Boom died, Boom Loud Protected N2: George died, Seven Loud Protected Seven - Neighborizer N1: Naybor George N2: Naybor Laser somi - Chat Checker N1: Chat check JC - none N2: Chat check Glue - none moody - Tracker-Watcher N1: Tracked Seven and somi, Watched bessie and LG - none N2: Tracked EGW a...

Gluelock wrote: ↑Sun Oct 22, 2023 12:38 am Okay well, it looks like JC isn't going to participate further. Who's next in the lineup, @Laserguy?

I'm CelestAI, Town JOAT. Tracker/Watcher/redacted
I tracked EGW N1, visited BoomFrog.
Watched Adum N2, saw moody and JC.
I have a third power that I am not intending on claiming.

Seven wrote: ↑Sat Oct 21, 2023 10:30 pm Does Laser even realize the deadline is today. Not sure what he means about not hammering before he comes back, but he's not gonna be back til like 1am my time.

I do, and yes, it's a terrible time for me. I'll do what I can on mobile.

As per usual, I don't play until evening on weekends so I won't be around much before deadline. Would greatly appreciate if we don't hammer early this time around.

Seven wrote: ↑Sat Oct 21, 2023 5:15 am

bessie wrote: ↑Sat Oct 21, 2023 4:48 am @Seven Why George? Why not Boom?

George was scumreading me and I wanted to talk to him about it + prove my claim.

Why was this so important? You were scumreading EGW as well for part of D1 at least. Why not try to team up with the possible mason group, for example?

bessie wrote: ↑Sat Oct 21, 2023 4:48 am @Seven Why George? Why not Boom?

Why me, for that matter? You were scumreading me EoD2 and EGW was too. @Seven

I'm interpreting this as a weirder and more experimental game which I guess would put this in Madge's wheelhouse, where town depends on scum at least to a degree, but not experimental enough for a three man scum lynched team. I've never seen that but I have seen games where scum were expected to cr...

moody7277 wrote: ↑Sat Oct 21, 2023 3:17 am N1 Tracked Seven and somi, Watched bessie and LG
N2 Tracked EGW and Makhaira, Watched Seven and Adum

I think this claim is probably true. I have some further thoughts but I think I'll discuss later.

System.out.println(" I say if anyone agrees on claiming just go ahead in their next post. Ordering always takes forever. Alternatively, I’m content with just going in whatever order you give Adum. You’re town leader. Tell us what to do senpai I like sanity checks, which is why I wanna get Lase...

System.out.println(" I say if anyone agrees on claiming just go ahead in their next post. Ordering always takes forever. Alternatively, I’m content with just going in whatever order you give Adum. You’re town leader. Tell us what to do senpai I like sanity checks, which is why I wanna get Lase...