New XKCD Forums

@Everyone : thoughts on massclaiming toDay? My concern is since it's 3-2 imo, it's likely we have to nail scum continuously from ToMorrow on to have a realistic chance of winning and having one extra lynch is useful for piecing out contradictory claim. My initial feeling is that next day would be b...

Uh, okay, bessie is really obviously EGW's buddy. Bookmarking this post! I may be referring back to it for years! I'm not quite sure what to make of this reaction and I'm just going to kind of put in a pin in it for now. I guess I appreciate you actually acknowledging this post since nobody else se...

Basically trying to figure out if we can be confident moody isn't Human. I think he's a fairly safe. As I suggested, I don't think it's a full clear because one scum bussing and one scum almost bussing is a thing I've seen before, but IDK I feel like humans going with an everyone bus all the time s...

System.out.println(" EGW and Bessie butting heads heavily Wait... when was this? I just documented a dozen cases of EGW going out of his way to defend bessie. You missed the point I was making. That was a hypothetical under Seven's 3 man mafia and SK scenario where Bessie knew the SK because s...

Congratulations on getting the 'obviously not mafia' gold star.

madge wrote: ↑Sun Oct 01, 2023 1:46 am 6. All chat is nightchat.

Nobody with chatting abilities can chat during the day phase.

I'm not going to try and force info out of the interaction because it wasn't some big brain plan. It was primarily done "for the lolz", work was really boring that day. Some take-aways that intrigued me though were: 1. Seven not intervening and allowing it to happen - This lines up with w...

AdumbroDeus wrote: ↑Thu Oct 19, 2023 9:04 pm EGW and Bessie butting heads heavily

Wait... when was this? I just documented a dozen cases of EGW going out of his way to defend bessie.

"Observation collapses quantum states." - El mighty BoomFrog My dude, you can't just make a handwave at BoomFrog and call it a BoomGambit, you have to draw some conclusions based on how people react. That's the whole point of the exercise "Observation collapses quantum states." ...

LaserGuy wrote: ↑Thu Oct 19, 2023 6:35 pm M2 targeted EGW N2 and kill him.

This should be M1

Okay, let's assume there's two mafias. M1 and M2 where M1 has the kill and M2 is human. M1 likely targeted Gluelock N1. So Glue is not M1. M2 targeted EGW N2 and kill him. EGW targeted BoomFrog N1 and Seven N2. Some votals: An interesting D1 votal here: Seven - 5 - Bessie, EGW , Boomfrog , Heury , S...

So, in looking at whether the loud mechanic has anything that stands out to it, I came across the basic role info on a scum doctor... In Mafia hands, the Doctor role has an additional, unrelated effect: a Mafia Doctor kills without the use of a gun , and thus a Gunsmith will not see a gun when inve...

JC_DADDY25 wrote: ↑Thu Oct 19, 2023 4:28 am Actually, Seven, you can clear me off your list of dissenters easily, because I would've killed you already.

There isn't really any way for you to demonstrate this so it isn't terribly useful. 'What I would do as scum' posts are usually considered pretty suspect hereabouts.

Seven wrote: ↑Thu Oct 19, 2023 2:55 am

Code: Select all

Evaluation Complete. 

Output:

Town (7): BoomFrog, Seven, GlueLock, Adumbrodeus, LaserGuy, somitomi, moody
Congruous Indy (1): heuristically_alone

Humans [unable to kill but typically town PRs](3): Zeniba, EGW, bessie
Dissenters [able to kill](2): Makhaira, JC

This seems very plausible to me.

I have had you as scum since D1. I put that read on the backburner late D1 as I thought you/heury were masons. Now that this is evidently not the case, it seems likely that you are just mafia. Ok. Who’s my partner(s)? Most likely EGW and Zeniba. EGW in particular was quite resistant to any of the p...

What did you intend to gain from your counterclaim @Gluelock Oh, and what made you stop? "Observation collapses quantum states." - El mighty BoomFrog I don't get this at all. Was this some sort of reaction test? Just for the lolz? I don't really feel like there's a scum motivation for thi...

System.out.println(" Uhhh @madge: Assuming it doesn't also end the game, would it be announced if a team is eliminated? In the event that a team is eliminated and the game doesn't end, said elimination will be announced. Well shit. This does somewhat revive the redirector/SK/potentially vig th...

JC_DADDY25 wrote: ↑Wed Oct 18, 2023 1:22 pm I took Seven's comment as sarcasm.

Just checking, which comment were you referring to here?

It just seems to be a very genuine "huh, I haven't thought of that" reaction that I think is very hard to fake if you're scum bullshitting us with the neighbourizer claim. It indicates a mindset so locked in on this reality that it never even occured to you how "EGW confirms your cla...

Vote: bessie With heury apparently not being a mason I'm feeling a lot less charitable. Please further explain this vote and your comment. I have had you as scum since D1. I put that read on the backburner late D1 as I thought you/heury were masons. Now that this is evidently not the case, it seems...

Seven wrote: ↑Wed Oct 18, 2023 12:50 am Anyway Blue is pulling your chains, he’s not in my hood. Laser was my only target.

Wut

What am I missing? It just seems to be a very genuine "huh, I haven't thought of that" reaction that I think is very hard to fake if you're scum bullshitting us with the neighbourizer claim. It indicates a mindset so locked in on this reality that it never even occured to you how "EG...

Madge said as far as she is aware all night actions were processed correctly, but no comment on the specific interaction.

I have asked and am awaiting word, though in expecting a 'no comment'.

Yes, this would be operating under the assumption Seven was lying about the mechanics of his role. Given past precedent, both within and outside this game, I don't really feel that is a huge stretch.

Oops, dunno how that double posted.