New XKCD Forums

Between work stuff, taxes, and just generally having to be a responsible adult, I couldn't keep focus long enough to hunt down and ISO dive Bessie's old games. That said, I did look part of the way back through this game. Notes: In retrospect, I think that guessing that Sniper's starting post was ro...

Seven wrote: ↑Sun Feb 06, 2022 1:16 am btw this PM system is a nightmare. Petition to use discord for submitting stuff in the future.

+1; it bugged me the number of times I had to resend things for SooT.

Secret Santa 2022: Oof at last minute pre-flip association from Boomfrog. Do not like. Bessie still scummiest scum to ever scum, regardless of Moody flip. I'mma try to towncase her and I guess metaread (gross) over the Night phase anyways just as a thought exercise. Rereading Boom and the Worst+WMU ...

If moody flips scum take a hard look at Madge and WMU. As I said, moody likes to be bussed. Madge was a tad early, but WMU fell right into place as the "oh, convince me why moodty is scum, mm, yeah that makes sense". That is a very typical maneuver for scum that have decided to bus. If mo...

I mean, as a general rule, and this is a core part of why I don't use cold meta usually, players who have more micro-macro contradictions than others, players who don't engage in good faith, players who play to an agenda rather than to an organic progression, players whose posts are forced and whos...

I mean, as a general rule, and this is a core part of why I don't use cold meta usually, players who have more micro-macro contradictions than others, players who don't engage in good faith, players who play to an agenda rather than to an organic progression, players whose posts are forced and whos...

But I think this elim should give us some good info.

May change over night.

Even though I don't get their perspective, I think Boom is still tied for top town for me with the worst...

You are really stuck in the double standard here. I literally asked you to disengage multiple times before you did and a bunch of people echoed me. Where? A bunch of people commented that the back and forth was frustrating but that's not the same thing as directly asking me to disengage. I was enga...

You can take the Bessie out of the argument but you can't take the argument out of the Bessie. Am I getting you right that you're essentially saying "Yes, she took a lot of convincing to even start to step away, and still hasn't engaged in good faith, but that's okay because #YOLO." as a ...

You are really stuck in the double standard here. I literally asked you to disengage multiple times before you did and a bunch of people echoed me. Where? A bunch of people commented that the back and forth was frustrating but that's not the same thing as directly asking me to disengage. I was enga...

I mean we like to vote to obtain a reaction, but here an early vote is ignored as meaningless. Then why is majority a thing here? Like, they're still using it. It's still not a plurality-only game. I haven't seen that much of XkCD games, but even on Smashboards, nobody was really considering plural...

Like, I stepped away from talking to Bessie of my own initiative. She's still a player in the game and I'm still reading and sorting her. But I decided of my own accord that it wasn't worth my time to let her control my play. But Bessie didn't have any such organic thought process. It was "Mult...

And she still took a lot of convincing to step even slightly away from the sarcasm, and never stepped away from the self-victimization. You can take the Bessie out of the argument but you can't take the argument out of the Bessie. Am I getting you right that you're essentially saying "Yes, she...

One of the things you found scummy about Madge is that she said Bessie is town, then voted for bessie. You find that behavior impossible to understand so decided it means she is scum. However, there are two things to consider. #1 that behavior doesn't make sense for scum either. Actually, scum migh...

Vote: Moody

Well at least this is also decently likely to flip scum.

So stop taking it as a given that you are innocent in everyone else's mind and that she should have seen the light and repented her wayward ways. I don't think this is really a fair representation of my case; I've been pointing out that her read on me isn't the problem, it's her unwillingness to so...

osieorb18 wrote: ↑Fri Feb 04, 2022 6:32 pm If votes don't change in the next half hour, I'll shift to Moody to self-preserve and to ensure that scum shenanigans away from them are less likely.

I'd still rather see Bessie on the chopping block, but moody is fine too.

If votes don't change in the next half hour, I'll shift to Moody to self-preserve and to ensure that scum shenanigans away from them are less likely.

This silence.. :( I was the presumptive elimination out of the three players I believe, so it wouldn't surprise me if scum sat back for that reason. However it doesn't entirely make sense because there was enough time that votes were not unlikely to change. So I'm thinking that scum plans to do som...

Like, I just don't understand how someone who is town would ever think that it's reasonable to be so persistently sarcastic, self victimizing, disingenuous, and inorganically sticking to something so vacuous and wrong... so proven to be such. I don't get the "it doesn't matter how wrong what I'...

@Boom - You see, where I run into an issue here... Even if you disregard the misrepresentations, which we can charitably call misinterpretations instead. Even if you disregard the appallingly lackluster and disproven case that Bessie has presented. Even if you disregard that Bessie has not really be...

xX_WakeMeUp1337_Xx wrote: ↑Fri Feb 04, 2022 5:07 pm Do we have plurality or majority?

Both

Madge is a crap shoot D1 in general, I've seen nothing alignment indicative from her all Day, she just really doesn't care about D1 as either alignment. She is a decent shot at scum by PoE, but I think Moody is actively scummy. He usually has at least something to say about every player but he only...