New XKCD Forums

Is there something particular about his [osie] content that strikes you as alignment indicative? / like I should have a read on him specifically? He is one of the few players that is familiar to you and has posted the most content. If you are trying to sort people he seems like the best place to st...

Is there something particular about his [osie] content that strikes you as alignment indicative? / like I should have a read on him specifically? He is one of the few players that is familiar to you and has posted the most content. If you are trying to sort people he seems like the best place to st...

some people mention the elephant in the room others ignore it completely. I feel like this implies that there may be at least one scum not in the wagons formed today thus far. I'm confident that this is only saying that some people aren't voting (or even posting). Why do you think this flavor is sp...

@osie, did you find my explanation of the role fishing incident convincing? Does it change your opinion of Bessie? I understand and understood since I posted it that someone could read rolefishing into that post, but pointed out from the start that it's an actively (intentionally?) uncharitable int...

a lot of his content has been bein cute (just osie things) Aww, you're cute too. osie prefers town I do? I thought I just pretty much never rolled anything else, to the level of being likely to roll vanilla town in a role madness game with excessive anti-town. osie in a vacuum I avoid hanging out i...

holy crap why did i agree to this game. thank you for saying i'm a good player but that's only as scum because i feel sneaky and manipulative!!!! you'll see my town game now and be AMAZED (at how bad it is) - this is also why so many xkcders gave me a free pass on all my erratic behaviour @osie, be...

holy crap why did i agree to this game. thank you for saying i'm a good player but that's only as scum because i feel sneaky and manipulative!!!! you'll see my town game now and be AMAZED (at how bad it is) - this is also why so many xkcders gave me a free pass on all my erratic behaviour @osie, be...

From the outside world I know osie and I know wmu. I don't think ive actually seen WMU's scumgame but she can be a badass as town so it'd be interesting I guess. Osie is also good scum and it's been a hot minute but I feel like I have a p decent shot at reading him. How do you feel about WMU this g...

From the outside world I know osie and I know wmu. I don't think ive actually seen WMU's scumgame but she can be a badass as town so it'd be interesting I guess. Osie is also good scum and it's been a hot minute but I feel like I have a p decent shot at reading him. How do you feel about WMU this g...

the worst wrote: ↑Mon Jan 31, 2022 10:08 pmI'm not the type of player who does things randomly without at least coming up with an excuse for it.

I am. Banana.

really interested in Snide's role, including what has been interpreted as rolefishing here Also... What? I made one post stating that a post which might be a hint at a killing role made me feel that Sniper was more likely to be town. That's it. That's not "really interested." Not in the s...

some people mention the elephant in the room others ignore it completely.

I feel like this implies that there may be at least one scum not in the wagons formed today thus far.

ust think you are going to a lot of effort to counter punch, which suggests at the very least you think she could be persuasive (not untrue btw). Comparably, this may be fair. For me at least, this isn't very much effort; if I was at full blast this game, I'd probably have more posts than are alrea...

Starts focusing on bessie after she begins tunneling If you consider "FoS osieorb18" to be tunneling... Given that I was the first person to question bessie at all. If anything, I had the gall to question what she was doing and she took that as an excuse to expand one of her scummy feeler...

Anyways, heading to bed, but bessie misrepping me non-stop just isn't fun to play with. Like, what the heck is this progression? Bessie goes: FoS osieorb18 I make 5 posts in the thread, one of which is asking if she's considering a pre-game post to be alignment-relevant. I ignore the naked "FoS...

That series of posts is so classic Town!worst but I don't know that it's out of their scumrange...

Worst's last two posts, given their nature, feel more like an attempt to pocket me than to pocket Madge, lol.

Hmm. Townlean? Maybe reconsidering on D2.

the worst wrote: ↑Mon Jan 31, 2022 7:28 amlike osie/bessie definitely qualifies as more interesting than rvs

More interesting? Maybe. Definitely less enjoyable. I suppose this is probably the second or third cringiest, most blatant series of misrepresentations formed into a push on me I've seen outside of games with the twins.

Wmu and The Worst, you both seem familiar with Osie's meta. Didn't you play with me at some point on Smashboards? Maybe not. We have, we played one game together as town but you were misyeeted D1 against my sole protests if I recall correctly. And you subbed in for scum in Vanilla Mafia but apparen...

I'm going to nip this in the bud because I know Bessie and she won't convince you on this but her assessment of potential role fishing is legitimate. (Also importantly I won't get alignment info out of watching you two squabble about it, but it will flood the thread if not nipped) Your post to TSS ...

you threw out an observation and tried to provoke a discussion (“ Softclaiming a killing role is... townie?”). More misrep. I wasn't "trying to provoke a discussion". I was stating, very straight-forward, that I thought it might be townie, but I wasn't certain. Given what I'd seen of Snip...

I’m not pointing out that you are putting notes in thread. I am accusing you of rolefishing. And again, I ask "Why would someone just put out there in the thread that they think that someone's softclaim is town as a form of rolefishing? How does that signify rolefishing?" Asking about it ...

madge wrote: ↑Sun Jan 30, 2022 11:38 pm vote bessie

just because the worst has a mini-wagon and id on't want to add to RVS

FWIW bessie's attitude to me is a null-tell. i think overall townie lean.

Wait, you're townleaning bessie in the same post that you're voting for them?

I'm more than happy to switch to bessie, but don't see it being useful to grow a wagon there until mid-Day if my overall gut judgment of their playstyle is correct.

Bessie shading me for "active lurking" when there were less than 40 posts since start of game and 4 out of 9 players (Heury/Boom/Moody/Sniper) hadn't really posted significant content is bugging me even more than her looking at posts prior to game start for alignment, but I could see this ...