New XKCD Forums

@Makhaira, while you are responding to my above request for reasons why you think I am scummy, can you also explain why, if there is a Day 4, you are so certain that you will be a part of it?

me eido phillip conf town at this point till endgame basically lets be real And what makes you say this? None of you are confirmed town to me. Some of you are likely town to me, but nothing is confirmed unless it is posted in modvoice. gotta be either somitomi or messie and obviously given everythi...

Eido wrote: ↑Wed Mar 16, 2022 5:54 am I’m here. On phone so it will be hard.

Unofficial votals:

BoomFrog (4): Eido, phillip, Mark_Cangila, Makhaira
Wam (3): somitomi, BoomFrog, messie
Makhaira (1): Wam

Eido, its up to you, you can stay on Boom or switch to Wam, that's about the only choice.

Makhaira wrote: ↑Wed Mar 16, 2022 5:51 am I get that Ill prob be MLed if boom flips town but I mean if he's town we're all lost af lets be real

I know we should have probably gone for Philip.

I'm just going to keep posting any thoughts I have until deadline. BoomFrog you should do the same.

Even considering the current votes, I still see a strong possibility of a somitomi-Wam team (refer to my end of Day 1 comments on this). Wam had no votes when somitomi voted, and was an unlikely elimination (I think I was the only one strongly suspecting him).

im kind of at a point right now where it has to be like either as simple as boom/messie or im like completely wrong and am getting played by someone like wam or mark. I really feel like eido is town and somi feels like a lost townie barely paying attention but like having genuine reactions I just r...

Unofficial votals:

BoomFrog (3): Eido, phillip, Mark_Cangila
Wam (3): somitomi, BoomFrog, messie
Makhaira (1): Wam

Not voting: Makhaira


So Makhaira it looks like it’s up to you, unless somitomi logs in but its 7am for him.

boomfrog wrote: ↑Wed Mar 16, 2022 4:44 am He's said phillip was likely town but still wants to eliminate him.

Do you not think there may be another reason for this that is irrelevant to Philip's alignment? Think creatively.

Hmmm, I wonder if somitomi will be awake in time to check the thread.

Unvote

Vote: Wam


No changes to my previous Woof-Grr list.

Can everyone that hasn't already done so post an ordered list (no groupings) before deadline?

Vote: somitomi

Placeholder. Open to discussion.

I feel BoomFrog and Makhaira are not-scum.

Makhaira wrote: ↑Wed Mar 16, 2022 3:13 am messie why not boom?

I get a not-scum feeling from him.

Just got home got something I need to do (I brought work home) but was thinking about this. The player with the most votes at the end of the day, regardless of how many votes that is, will be eliminated. A majority is not required. In the event of a tied vote, the player who reached the highest numb...

This is where my little puppy brain is at. No explanations now because I’m in a hurry but I want to get this out there because its 3 hours until deadline. Woof Heury Sabrar messie Mark_Cangila BoomFrog Makhaira Eido philip Wam somitomi Grr My people need to drive someone home and I get to go for a r...

pretty sure these posts alone give us greater insight into each of these players than the rest of what has happened this phase in its entirety lmao I’m sure the answer is there if one is enlightened enough to see it. we also have a no elim to burn, do we want to consider doing that to buy us some t...

Sorry this was supposed to be in my last post. My little puppy mind goes crazy when I hear “pizza”! How are you planning to solve Phillip this game btw? I don’t need to solve Philip. If I solve enough other people, Philip will eventually sort himself. All I need to solve is the question of his conti...

Woof. Woof woof woof. Woof woof. Woof? Woof! Advising phillip only takes a few minutes. Game solving takes a computer and a few hours. Working on it now though. Also, we can't afford to eliminate phillip if he is town, so advising him about LYLO tactics is very worthwhile. Yes, I meant continue advi...

Woof! Today is my birthday and my people got me a cake! I tried to eat the whole thing at once and they took it away and gave me a little piece. But they left it on the counter and now I am just waiting for them to leave. hoku birthday cake.PNG Wam, you didn’t provide a reply to this: This doesn’t a...

Still working on my daily catch up, but I feel this deserves its own post. i don't think i'll play mafia again. i don't really know how to fully participate with meaningful posts. interesting game, but not for me. Philip, I appreciate that you keep posting and that you appear to want to do what’s be...

this slot is just going to grow into a bigger and bigger problem as the game goes on without a serious change of course I’m having a lot of trouble justifying keeping Philip in the game for reasons including these. He’s being mentored by osieorb so he should be improving, not declining. That’s why ...

Oh boy my person dropped a carrot on the ground I'm a happy dog right now! what's up with the L-1 thing next to me? Philip, can you please ask your mentor to explain this, and what “L-1” means to the game, and how it may be seen as suspicious? It's not just sabrar's view as well the more I look at t...

Makhaira wrote: ↑Fri Mar 11, 2022 7:02 pm Vote: Boomfrog

Please unvote until we can have more discussion.

@Wam, can I have your opinion on philip's Day 1 content and vote?

Woof! Sorry I didn’t post last night I was very busy working! My people went out for a while and when they are gone it is my job to guard the house! And they gave me an extra job on top of that! They gave me a new toy before they went away in the car! My job when I get a new toy is to rip it open, p...

somi can't vote heury because one of his scum reads (me) is voting heury.