New XKCD Forums

How did you do the first without seeing two kinds of doctor listed? And when did you learn you could click the spoilers? For the first question, I assume you mean that all the info in the OP was copypasted from the signup thread? I mostly just got the "town picks for scum, scum picks for town&...

I think you guys may be using town slip as synonymous with town tells. I consider a slip to be an accidental reveal of one's alignment due to a mistake or misunderstanding. A tell is an indicator of one's alignment. A town slip is one form of a town tell. For example, Swiss being eager and inquisit...

I'd also appreciate you quoting where Fred has townslipped. How can you have possibly missed it? You read carefully. You think this is fake?? Frozen (Mak) is town. Really wish you hadn't said that. We could have used this to subtly bait out dumb scum trying to train Mak. Literally just put that in ...

And when did you learn you could click the spoilers?

boomfrog ... post 11: asks me about why there are two types of docs and about vig I think I missed the point of the first question because I only knew about the regular type of doctor previously ... @moody when and how did you learn what a weak doc is? I learned of the existence of such a role at t...

Unrelated, why were you ready to end Day 0 so soon? I find it interesting considering that your intro post was about being busy. Wagons weren't going to change so no real information was being generated. If we had infinite RL time I decreased our win chance, but since we don't I'd rather cut some s...

Apart from the one you were replying to, one that stood out to me was Mak's about the role cop having a chance at being insane. When it was mentioned that we could click on the roles to see how they worked I clicked on all of them to see what they were. I don't know if anyone else did that, but I f...

moody7277 wrote: ↑Wed Dec 06, 2023 2:22 am boomfrog
...
post 11: asks me about why there are two types of docs and about vig

I think I missed the point of the first question because I only knew about the regular type of doctor previously
...

@moody when and how did you learn what a weak doc is?

Ebwop:

moody - fairly null but good* analysis so far.

My answer depends on who the scum team are. If its a steong scum team and can generally appear town as scum I would go for the vig/mason/weak doc combination and hope the weak doc and Mason target scum and take themselves out and the vig hammwrs town. If the team is weaker and generally appears mor...

Cool, I'm caught up. Town Freddino - town slipped repeatedly Makhaira - I think the cumulative slips add up to sincere. Sabrar- good analysis, giving away a lot of town clears. bessie - town slip is likely real. Only scum with fonti or seven. Seven - giving out the Mak town clear was very townie unl...

+ for zen sus What points did sabrar make about Zen's alignment here? P.S. it would greatly help my phone posting if you broke up your posts more, ty. Just saw - I acquiesce. Points? Unsure, but Zen was approaching Bessie with sus/careful questioning, is how I read it. You didn't see this? What do ...

Kevin Kline in Hamlet , Act III, Scene 2. It means I have my doubts about Seven’s sincerity. I'm very confident (but never 100% sure) that Seven's explination of the timeline of her thoughts is sincere. And my ability to read tone is significantly stronger then yours, so proportional to how much yo...

EBWOP: wam Not* really

With that said I think I found a potential town-slip by wam. Don't want to leave this for D2. I think wam's approach to fake-claiming here does not come from a scum pov due to the nature of the setup. Wam thinks that scum could use janitor to get a safe fake claim, but scum actually already have tw...

Boom what was the intent behind asking what town roles people would have assigned? Did you get what you were looking for? Yes, I got a couple town clears from it. Although one was Mak and Sabrar and Fonti have me rethinking that, but still leaning town on him so far. What specifically were you look...

Seven, hey my dude, I feel kind of bored with you this game. I'm not used to that feeling, and I'm wondering if it means you're scum. What's up? I’m curious to see if bessie has an explanation for this. Are you intentionally playing this game for any specific reason? Ignore this, I got to your expl...

Seven wrote: ↑Tue Dec 05, 2023 9:46 pm

fontisian wrote: ↑Tue Dec 05, 2023 1:32 pm Seven, hey my dude, I feel kind of bored with you this game. I'm not used to that feeling, and I'm wondering if it means you're scum. What's up?

I’m curious to see if bessie has an explanation for this.

Are you intentionally playing this game for any specific reason?

Wam wrote: ↑Tue Dec 05, 2023 4:58 pm

Swiss wrote: ↑Tue Dec 05, 2023 4:33 pm sure why not

request deadline extension

My view is that there are several players that I want to hear more from before the EOD.

Short list off the top.of my head:
Madge
Fred
JC

Why am I not on this list?

Interesting. I think my view of the math part is the same across ganes, regardless of my alignment, because it's actually complimentary with scum thoughts on misyeets. I think this is a poor reason to townread me. Obviously you know your own mind better, I don't think this topic ever came up previo...

+ for zen sus What points did sabrar make about Zen's alignment here? P.S. it would greatly help my phone posting if you broke up your posts more, ty. Just saw - I acquiesce. Points? Unsure, but Zen was approaching Bessie with sus/careful questioning, is how I read it. You didn't see this? But Sabr...

@Seven, swiss and fonti and anyone else who asked me about this, Did you *not* get anything out of it? I thought my reasons where pretty clear to anyone on S team which is why I didn't care about their answers. I can think of at least 4 perfectly normal reasons off the top of my head why you would ...

@ boomfrog : here you are asking moody to speculate on why the setup has both doc and weak doc as an option. moody misinterprets the question here . what was the purpose of the question and why did you not follow-up like you have with others? Hmm, I remember thinking about clarifying and deciding n...

1. Boomfrog lurky null 2. Wam scumleanny 3. Swiss godfather 4. Mak townlean 5. Fred null town 6. Madge null town 7. Seven scumlean 8. moody need to check 9. JC town 10. Fonti town 11. bessie scumlean 12. Sabrar townlean I would kill (do we use kill? whats the word? kill is too vague) Zen/Bessie/Wam...

Please explain. I genuinely have no idea what I’ve done. Watching HaiLOWEEN from the sidelines reinforced my belief that your play is disruptive to Town. + for zen sus What points did sabrar make about Zen's alignment here? P.S. it would greatly help my phone posting if you broke up your posts more...