New XKCD Forums

vote maven

well if J or Maven is here now would be a great time for a claim

heuristically_alone wrote: ↑Wed Aug 23, 2023 1:53 am Lower means more scummy.

that doesn't answer the question in a meaningful way.

why is mak more of a town lean for you than I am?

Hmm, since we won't have time to have a martyr claim after J and Maven post, how does this plan sound?

Bessie claims her N3 target in advance, and that person claims martyr/not martyr. If they're the martyr then obviously Bessie swaps target.

Do you *really* think me clarifying for Bessie that "her being confirmed" =/= "her being dead" stagnated today, and not, you know, half the thread being horribly inactive?

I think you missed my point. I wasn't chastising you for being patronizing. I'm just telling you it's not going to get the effect you want. If you want to say the question sniping is patronizing, that's fine. It got me the effect I wanted and I'm okay with that. I do disagree that doing it twice in ...

"I don't think the question you're asking is good so I'm gonna cut it off" is EXTREMELY patronizing. And you've done it to several people. Two is not several, but that's not really relevant anyway. Fundamentally, my concern is advancing the gamestate in a way that I think is the most prod...

@mod can we prod J? been almost 70h since last post

i appreciate your point of view, but being patronizing about it isn't going to convince me it's correct from a mafia theory standpoint. we can have that discussion if it's truly that important to you, but again I think there are better lines to pursue. Speaking of mafia theory - don't push the uncla...

nah, it's the same thing I was talking to egw about - I want to prune lines of conversation that are less productive imo so there's more focus on the things I care about

Also, don't want any hammers ATM because we still haven't finished the seer claums, it's 5 to lynch and right now the votes are: Maven: 2 (myself, Heuristic) Prince J: 2 (Mak, Freddino) If Bessie is unCCed, we also need the Martyr to claim before day's end so they don't get investigated. Nobody ham...

at this point I think we just kill maven/j and let Bessie handle the other. the slots aren't going to get more sortable

you don't need to be dead - pj and maven not CCing you is confirmation itself

1. EGW - Vanilla
2. PJ
3. Adum - Not Seer
4. somi - Sorcerer
5. heury - Not seer
6. bessie - Claimed Seer
7. Mak - Not Seer
8. Fred - Not Seer
9. Maven
10. moody - not seer
11. Dooplisity - Not Seer

Just need Maven and PJ to actually be in the thread.

ok, now can we all get the seer/not seer claims out

anyway more seriously I would like bessie to out their n2 result because this day is clearly pretty stagnant otherwise and it would help analysis

Heury's dropped off my radar a bit, but his posts feel a bit light to me, like he's just coasting along. Not entirely sure what to make of that yet, I have a hard time reading Heury. Oh I've definitely been coasting along, but next week I'll be in California so scum be in fear for some scary heury ...

Your N0 being on me marginally increases the chances the other two are scum. If all 3 are town it could hit anyone, but if one is scum it can't hit them and if both are scum it has to hit me. I don't think it's particularly valuable information due to how marginal it is. In a perfectly logical world...

I still need to go read over Somi's slot and analyze it but I'm obvtown/potentially clear and also super busy with family from out of state this weekend so I'd love to see others do it first

I would rather not claim right away, and I will give you my reasoning as to why. If I have a wolf result, then D2 is over and we lose our last chance of getting some wolf-wolf interactions to analyze on D3. When I claim I will also give my reasoning as to why I selected my target. I don't agree wit...

Freddino18 wrote: ↑Sat Aug 19, 2023 7:00 am I have a question for Seven. If the Hunter is NK'ed and chooses to kill the Martyr's target, does the target die or does the Martyr die?

I can answer this. The Martyr dies (and also town is very sad)

It should basically never happen though.

the martyr or bessie not being dead does mean they didn't attack bessie but i could reasonably see that as a gambit (scum is super fucked from this gamestate imo)

Nobody else claim seer or not seer at present ...why? we have a martyr alive and a claimed seer if bessie is the seer then we still get another clear out of her, and we take 3 people out of the scum pool (myself, bessie, bessie's n1 clear) if bessie is not the seer then since the sorc is dead, she ...

I take it you are not thefather seer then?

also at some point we definitely have to go back and re-read somi with the knowledge that they knew who the wolves are, but I can't do that right now