New XKCD Forums

This is my last reads list with suzkaku and Heury removed pending any potential flips/rez. My head hasnt really moved on from there.

Town
jimbob
laserguy
somitomi
BoomFrog
moody7277
bessie
Snide sniper
patzer
Scum

Happy to be an old hand involed if it goes ahead.

@bessie I didnt mean to justify it I was trying to state that I can't see why scum patzer would hammer therefore it's more likely to be an accident. I think it's odd your throwing shade for this? Especially when we don't know Huery's alignment. Hint of TMI Bessie why do you think final thoughts from...

@jimbob I thought you were looking for something like that. But I think it did come across that if snide is mafia they haven't thought through the full implications of a mafia member being recruited. Which is that the cult then know all the mafia members, powers and plans. Which means the mafia is d...

When did this thought occur to you? What about if the cult "recruited" the mafia member, but the recruit's win condition didn't change? Can I answer ;) In a bit, but I want The Snide Sniper's response specifically (I'll explain later, if I can remember my reasoning). I have a vague idea o...

jimbobmacdoodle wrote: ↑Wed Oct 06, 2021 2:47 pm
When did this thought occur to you? What about if the cult "recruited" the mafia member, but the recruit's win condition didn't change?

Can I answer

Halloween mafia :!: so we killed suzaku apologies. If all the flips are at noon that's going to make the first half each day a bit weird and dead. If we dont get all the flips or flips until much later that makes the game more scumsided which will help. Otherwise still managing to get town read alwa...

FWIW, I suspect there's at least one player with a "Morning" day action to resurrect a player who died that night. Dead cult members not appearing in the total means a) Heuristically_alone was not the Cult Leader and b) Suzaku is only Cult if he was recruited last night before being kille...

Morning all. @bessie you now have an example for the discssuikn we had on smashboards about accidental hammers. For the record I do believe it was an accident by patzar. Also it's not like we lost much of the day so I can't see any real advantage to scum patzar doing a fake accidental hammer. Not ge...

Congratulations!!!

Halloween :!: So I didnt want to say anything early but I have finally rolled scum again. I think the first time since stellaris! Think I managed to be slightly less scim read than normal day 1 which is good. Am worried about the jimbob LG boom town block as well as the cult out there. Also if my pa...

LaserGuy wrote: ↑Sun Oct 03, 2021 7:20 pm I'm not planning on voting today unless it is to break a tie, but you can consider my vote to be on heury.

Why ?

I will be around for deadline but I'm worried that we are 16 hours from deadline, thread is dead.

FYI L-3

Right sorry for the delay but I'm not alone in that one! Also my brain is still foggy from the cold (not Covid) I have so if the below doesn't make sense I'm sorry! My detailed reads are below but my main concern from yesterday is Huery elimination just feels easy. As per Sabrar's usual logic that i...

LaserGuy wrote: ↑Fri Oct 01, 2021 11:52 pm @heury: So everyone is Town?

This so much this.

@jimbob did wonder if you were reaction fishing.

More later been fighting a cold yesterday brain is much more in gear today.

@patzer why do you associated activity with being town?

@jimbob waiting with baited breath for your case this evening.

Why is this not a stronger scum read? Apart from him being my second scum pick after heury? Mainly because it's only two posts (Hello kettle, my name's pot), which could be due to IRL issues and lack of time to read through the thread in detail. The same level of reads after more posts and clearly ...

Ebwop: suzaku can you also expand your bessie read?

@Suzaku given your statement


"patzer - needs more content. one RVS vote and one pretty weak reads post."

Why is this not a stronger scum read?

@wam, why do you find Sniper to be scum? What's changed since your null read on him? https://ramenchef.net/nxf/viewtopic.php?p=7165#p7165 I went back and forth on the reads list above this morning. I'm getting vibes of a newbie scum trying to make a reads list without showing TMI. Its missing what ...

Looks like my questions didn' catch Heury's attention... Vote: Heuristically_alone I'm going to give somi a town lean for this I dont think scum somi would be so pushy. Do you not find it interesting that Wam didn’t leave his vote long enough for it to show up in the votals? I wonder if it really w...

If wam's comment about -1 for not noticing his vote was on the mod is serious, I don't know what to think... It didn't seem worth commenting on from my point of view, and I expect several others were similar. @wam, re. meta read of heury, what do you remember of his meta? Last game I played was a s...

heuristically_alone wrote: ↑Wed Sep 29, 2021 2:54 pm Yeah snide sniper is not gonna be my vote today.

Why?

heuristically_alone wrote: ↑Wed Sep 29, 2021 11:23 am

Wam wrote: ↑Wed Sep 29, 2021 7:22 am Huery is interesting more involved that I normally remember but I think that's a town indication for them on meta.

Don't worry. I'm sure I'll devolve back to my normal self as the game goes on.

Why because the effort of pretending to play to your town meta will be too hard?