New XKCD Forums

I’ll claim tomorrow if people still have an issue with me, but 1) I would not have let Sabrar die the way he did without claiming 2) I am doubly capable of killing a player, both ways indirectly. I will vote off Math, moody, or Suzaku. I’m suspicious of the worst but I think I know their role so I’l...

Also, sorry osie, but I fucking hate this “vote affects power” mechanic.

I originally voted Suzaku because Jedi was voting him, and then Jedi moved either right before or right after I voted. At that point I was pretty much willing to vote any non-townread, hence the switch.

I think madge is town. Or at least townier than the other people I mentioned, but I'll acknowledge that I know literally nothing about her. She just seems authentically alone, i.e. not working with a mafia team. Could be neutral, I guess. I threw Suzaku in there too because they're very absent/low i...

Never mind, I get it now and I'm probably a dumdum. Please ignore most of that.

Oh, never mind, he said he has an active ability but not a targeting one. I...don't have a clear understanding of the difference, especially when another player is involved.

That's all the spam from me, sorry.

(Not my intention to rolefish, but if you put out information that feels contradictory, I'm going to question it.)

For that matter, I'm wondering how the worst can be blocked at all if he doesn't have an active ability.

I don't think I read that post, rip. My bad!

Morgan, can you talk through why you seem to be approaching this conversation from a pov where Seven is town but you're also not particularly motivsted to defend him or explain the read? Any way I try to spin this, it looks like you're approaching this from a scum perspective. Doesn't really tell m...

Sabrar (6/8) - bessie, wam, SuperJedi224, Morgan, Wisp, xX_WakeMeUp1337_Xx
SuperJedi224 (5/8) - madge, the worst, Sabrar, MathBlade, moody7277
Wisp (1/8) - Seven
moody7277 (1/8) - Suzaku

Kill [the worst, MathBlade, moody, Suzaku], achieve victory.

Vote MathBlade

Yeah I am now 99% convinced that all the other mafia were offline or lurking when Sabrar died.

madge wrote: ↑Mon Nov 29, 2021 2:21 am Daychat is my biggest fear in games so I checked this when we started and:

osieorb18 wrote: ↑Tue Nov 16, 2021 8:41 am Players with chats can chat at any time.

lmaoooo, thanks.

I will admit I have little interest in mafia these days. I intended to quit forever, but here I am, and I am very much enjoying not putting in as much effort as I used to [without compromising my team's ability to win, of course]. As for not being interested in solving the game, 1) ok, why not engag...

@bessie i don't think Morgan is interested in solving the game. When they do give opinions, I'm not convinced that they're actually saying stuff that they believe is true. Seven is an easy player to have an opinion on right now. I was think the way Morgan is remaining as noncommittal is a very safe...

I kind of want to assume scum don't have daychat (or they really were all absent from the thread), because I can't imagine them *not* encouraging Sabrar to claim vigilante. Like........really.

I never understood the importance some players put on safeclaims. You are assuming that powers must be alignment indicative, which I feel in this game would not be cut and dried. If Sabrar wanted to claim he could have just claimed his real role (and Sabrar could have come up with a fake claim were...

I may not be the best scum hunter but anyone who actively makes it harder to do so and refuses to address the thread and work together is a great elim. I feel that the problem with this viewpoint is that it’s not beneficial to the game, in that you declaring this discourages scum hunting for the re...

Would also like Wam to exist more.

I'm not really getting anything from ISO'ing. All of Math's/Sabrar's/Seven's posts feel like white noise.

I'll try again tomorrow, maybe do a broader search of the thread.

I really want to see Michelle's catch-up.

Oh, I just remembered a Thought.

Sabrar being unwilling to claim at the first deadline means that scum are unlikely to have fakeclaims. If he had one and didn't use it, then lol.

You really should get an avatar, Math. It takes thirty seconds.

(Reading now.)

You know what, ignore my checking Jedi is a waste thing. I always try to assume too much about the setup.

The irony now is that if MathBlade doesn’t follow worst’s vote, he’ll be impeding the town by blocking a check on another player. lmao

Also, the worst suggesting an alignment check on Jedi of all people is a waste. How about we look for mafia in the people who are more actively shaping the game, unless there’s a hidden benefit to knowing Jedi’s alignment that I’m missing. Someone said that scum!Jedi having a more important role tha...

Because whenever a case is based on fakeclaiming, it usually gets pushed devoid of logic or actual reasonable conversation “because he LiEd tO tHe ToWn” and I don’t care enough to engage in that kind of discourse. I’d rather eat the (potential) miselim and bitch about it after the fact. But you’re r...