New XKCD Forums

That was all at the start of D1. We are well into D2 now.

@jimbob I will look at your post in more detail when I get to a computer and can cross-reference properly. One thing that did stick out is that patzer is definitely not a newbie and should be well aware that mafia can and do bus.

Yes, survivor is scum, but spending two yeets to flip a zero information slot is not a winning strategy. I think your slot has a somewhat low chance of being core mafia, so I would prefer to invest our energy elsewhere at this stage. Wam is much more cautious this game. In WWZ he was fairly active i...

Hi Zen! Thanks for replacing. Hi guys, as YOLO stated, my name is Zen. It will just be easier if you refer to me as Zyth though. When I tried making an account it kept saying that I was a spammer >_>. Anyways, I'm Dgames' best player. I've won 90% of the games that I've been town and I usually have ...

Couple quick things. I am working on mobile so I'm not going to quote anything. I will try to be more comprehensive later. -Thinking on it more, I think Heury is actually a bad yeet for today and am moderately suspicious of the three votes on him (wam, moody, jimbob) for pushing this. I think Heury ...

I'm on holidays for the next couple days. I will try to keep up with the thread but don't expect much out of me until after the weekend.

I really hope we're not going to have to yeet everyone twice this game. I'm not opposed to yeeting heury again in principle so we can at least have a result, but it feels kind of a waste. Somitomi answered your question (he has also since answered your follow-up). My question was for you. I'm trying...

That question was for somitomi and he hasn’t answered my follow up question on the top of page 7 yet. Have you read my page 7 post or are you just picking out random stuff to comment on? Somitomi answered your question (he has also since answered your follow-up). My question was for you. I'm trying...

Not getting flips upfront is going to drag the early part of each day out... I'm really hoping we'll get them at Noon, if they aren't resurrected. If we don't (possibly because resurrection can happen on a later Day), we're going to be heavily relying on investigative roles, I feel. The rules don't...

I'm not really sure the best way to proceed without any flip info. Will need to think about it.

@Madge: Will we be informed if a faction is eliminated entirely (even if there is a chance their member(s) could be resurrected)?

Wam wrote: ↑Sun Oct 03, 2021 8:41 pm

LaserGuy wrote: ↑Sun Oct 03, 2021 7:20 pm I'm not planning on voting today unless it is to break a tie, but you can consider my vote to be on heury.

Why ?

Because I think Heury is scum, but don't want to actually vote today for reasons.

I'm not planning on voting today unless it is to break a tie, but you can consider my vote to be on heury.

Apologies I didn't get around to posting further yesterday. It was a busy day, and today may be similar, though I don't know. Hopefully I'll have the time to work on some full reads later on, including finishing my Snide Sniper analysis. I'll post a serious vote either way by the end of my day. I'l...

Apologies I didn't get around to posting further yesterday. It was a busy day, and today may be similar, though I don't know. Hopefully I'll have the time to work on some full reads later on, including finishing my Snide Sniper analysis. I'll post a serious vote either way by the end of my day. I'l...

Just a note for deadline planning: The deadline is at 2:00 am my time and will be even later for people east of me in the US/Canada, so I expect a bunch of us will probably not be around for the last several hours of the day phase.

@patzer why do you associated activity with being town? This is a very tentative list where I've got nothing else to go on. It's feasible that scum could be less active to fly under the radar, but it's not a strong indication; the issue is that nobody else other than heury and laser have pinged me ...

@heury: So everyone is Town?

@Suzaku, why do you think Snide Sniper is newbie town? Wait, why do we [/b] think jimbob is town? Allowing that we accept that TSS is a newbie, I don't think newbie scum (who would know, or given multiple factions, at least strongly suspect, that you are town (assuming you are, of course)) would ma...

Reads BoomFrog: Often he prefers to keep his play very ambiguous, especially in D1, but here I feel he's been pretty open about his thoughts and opinions, and I feel that he and I are approaching the game from a very similar perspective. Town. jimbob : jimbob seems really happy to be here and is thr...

Looking at everything that's gone on so far... Jimbob: Started off by trying to analyze the game mechanics and work out ways in which town can win. This could well be a bluff but I'm not sure if a mafia member would actually stick their neck out like that, so I'll tentatively lean town for him. Moo...

I also never claimed to be staying your point of view. I had also seen snide sniper's post as towny and I was stating why I thought so. Interesting that you jumped to the conclusion that I was attempting to explain your position. But... you said you weren't making a read of jimbob in this post . If...

I actually read snide sniper as town based on his response to Boomfrog. You mean this post? What feels townie about this reply to you? I actually feel like his reads so far are a bit superficial, but it's kinda early Who do you like as Town so far? Um, why? This may be a bit of a culture clash from...

Hallowe'en

Spoiler (Show/Hide)

My game notes are here
https://www.quicktopic.com/53/H/WBPvEwZqfBY

Please explain your reasoning because I do not agree. Notice I haven't made a read on Jimbob. But it does have a lot of we we we in it, referring to town. At the very least Jimbob is attempting to appear as having a town mindset as this is what the town mindset should be, is it not? I think if I we...

I see a question I know the answer to, I answer it. I'm that annoying kid at school that likes to sit on the front row. But now I want to know, do you agree with me? I think the question itself is NAI, and I have jimbob at null. I'm not sure exactly what BoomFrog is basing his analysis off of, but ...