New XKCD Forums

(side note to Mak, if you are scum that is the most brilliant play I have ever seen) ????????? what are you even referring to hahahaha this is so out of no where but fred posts actually feel like this have some soul in this game just further pushing my town read Wam would you bite on a Freddino eli...

I quote Zen/Seven/Xiivi "Obtuse. You never use to use such a word. I am seriously doubting you're the same person on the Ranmaru account. Either that or you were faking your personality all this time." https://smashboards.com/threads/dr-who-mafia-endgame-town-wins-the-universe-is-doomed.3...

Now I get Swiss' anger at the forum software. Sab feels off Your last comment about me prior to that was a scumlean on me because not voting D0, days ago. You have avoided reacting to my reply. Can you now elaborate? you're not a very effusive player to begin with, so I see scum!sab being even choo...

Request Extension

open to being wrong on bessie but idk slot feels normal to me

boom def conspicuously absent, seven way less engaged than normal, Sab feels off

need to reread tonight before possible tomorrow deadline and look at the rolecop voting wagon

I think it's odd that the two roles you found least threatening are the two roles you would hope for as scum. Fonti and Sabrar aren't misinterpreting anything. Considering which roles are the least threatening implies consideration of the roles town might have. FF respond to this please. I am tryin...

@Swiss I though Booms townslip was him overtly stating that his objection to janitor is grounded in his personal heavy reliance on flips for scumhunting. Seemed to be a legitimate bleeding of his town POV into the post as he legitimately seemed to feel like his own ability to play well this game wou...

@mak few questions apologies if already asked. How does anyone town aligned think giving scum day rolecop is a good idea like hello????? What of the other 4 scum roles is more town aligned to give scum? Why the sudden switch here to rolecop being better than at least 1, only 20 min later. https://r...

Sabrar what is your read on fonti? I like how they constantly reevaluated the roles D0. I don't agree with some of their opinion but they gave reasonable explanation. I've especially like this fresh perspective. do you believe anything about this alternative "mathy" take on the game strat...

Counter argument: janitor isn't actually that bad. It's a one shot, and it cannot target itself (so if we yeet them first, it's a useless role). It doesn't give scum extra kills and it gives our prs more space to maneuver. I think as long as we don't pair it with a godfather (because that would mea...

Not too heated fonti I dont take any personal offense to anything you said in that reply Whether you crossed your own personal boundary for heatedness is obv your own thing to decide but Im just letting you know that you didnt upset or offend me in any way, youre allowed to be annoyed by me if think...

Sabrar what is your read on fonti? I like how they constantly reevaluated the roles D0. I don't agree with some of their opinion but they gave reasonable explanation. I've especially like this fresh perspective. D1 they are expressing an opinion on a bunch of players (which again I like) but their ...

I think Fred is likely town on meta alone tbh

Seven what is your actual read on Sabrar* rn

Seven what is your actual read on Seven rn?

Sabrar what is your read on fonti?

Its actually unbeleiveable to me that anyone is defending people voting for giving scum the power to janitor their own mate's flip if we dont identify the janitor as scum first. It's arguably the most valuable flip we can get in this setup, especially so if the surviving mate actually tries to swing...

JC gonna be useless all game can already tell

Seven coming after me feels opportunistic af rn

My bessie townlean comes from me playing with town!bessie for atleast the last 2-3 games Ive been in with her and her style not really deviating from that baseline so far. Not a hard read by any means but it feels like town!bessie again to me here

Yo, I exist. [continuing where I left off] For the roles, I don't really have any context as to what's powerful and what isn't, other than the fact that some people seem to really hate Janitor. I feel like the roleblocker is kind of a dick move, but it seems like it can miss. Tentative vote for Rol...

Vote: Rolecop I'm leaning towards the janitor for my other choice tbh. Yeah it sucks to not be sure but there's a 1/3 chance that the first mafia we kill is the janitor and it is moot. madge plz explain all this plz respond plz I explained this in a later post on d0, I am not inclined to repeat mys...

bessie townlean

actual possibility of sab/fonti scumteam here if I called it Im popping off after the game

Sabrar not casting a single vote in the role voting phase really, really bothers me, scumlean tbh

madge wrote: ↑Thu Nov 30, 2023 5:48 am I would never give them a cop and a doctor of either stripe, obviously.

were you aware that cop had a 50% chance to be insane when you posted this?

FF I want to give you some leeway because Zen is posting hella different now. But I no likey. No likey at all. I won't be giving you leeway, but you should know that I want to. As an aside how I can remember Zen and your posting styles and not remember hydraing with Huery still blows me away. My mi...