New XKCD Forums

So sworn. If I die, don't tunnel him. This is Frozen telling me to not let scum!JC win, if he dies and I live. That's a. Not a scenario I was really expecting to happen and b. Something I will absolutely promise and then reneg on if I feel confident enough JC is town. If I fuck it up, I'll deal wit...

I'm too tired and I don't have the time for a reread or analysis to verify my gut, so you just get my memory and instincts. Seven's paranoia, and the vig shooting one of my hard town clears is just too much to deal with. I'm not going to hard carry this game. Fonti and Swiss are scum. Fonti for way ...

the push on JC could not have been foreseen as it came from Mak 3 hours later during the scramble. I doubt it's relevant but a push on JC as a low volume player near EoD was almost inevitable and was predictable as people couldn't find anything actually scummy to latch onto. It's a natural flow of ...

Swiss wrote: ↑Thu Dec 14, 2023 8:48 am

Swiss wrote: ↑Wed Dec 13, 2023 3:55 pm This two good examples thing makes no sense

@Boom

I don't care and your question is a dumb waste of time. Seven's not going to back down so I need to exactly figure out the solve so the vig can follow my reads. I don't have any time for your distractions.

madge makes the same mistake as bessie, by providing only 2 roles as an answer to boomfrog's question here. This never gets noticed by anyone :o I think I noticed this originally but then forgot. the weak doctor seems strictly worse than doctor as the weak doctor would really struggle to breadcrumb...

In an ideal world - Zen who would you yeet? Boom - who would you yeet Madge - who would you yeet Fonyt - who would you yeet in an ideal world whoever I yeet would be scum. But to answer your real question: Probably Fonti. Why did you ask me? I think my answer was extremely obvious. Why did you not ...

JC_DADDY25 wrote: ↑Wed Dec 13, 2023 2:45 pm

Seven wrote: ↑Wed Dec 13, 2023 11:50 am @JC thoughts on Swiss?

Haven't really felt like Swiss's posts have been coming from a scummy POV, and the post about you gloating in thread makes quite a bit of sense.

So you are keeping up with everything? Can you share your thoughts on everyone in thread?

fontisian wrote: ↑Wed Dec 13, 2023 2:44 pm VLA

Putting a pet to sleep.

Will ask for replacement if I'm for more than 24 hours.

Take care. That sucks.

In an ideal world - Zen who would you yeet? Boom - who would you yeet Madge - who would you yeet Fonyt - who would you yeet in an ideal world whoever I yeet would be scum. But to answer your real question: Probably Fonti. Why did you ask me? I think my answer was extremely obvious. Why did you not ...

@madge: I'm considering worlds where you are town and if so we need to vote together as a block. I like your sabrar theory, do you have any other reads that aren't based on speaker for the dead? What has stuck out to you this game? Just please type up what you are thinking because I do not have enou...

@fonti: can you provide a reads list please?

And I didn't think he faked the 'town slip' you identified. I thought that scum wam would say the same thing naturally because scum probably didn't talk about fake claiming strategy yet . So I didn't think it was alignment indicative. No, that's the opposite of what you said initially: Or this coul...

I was looking for similar slips such as what Mak and moody did. This is post hoc argument. You had moody at fairly null at that time. You asked him about the 2 doc thing eod but never drew the conclusion that it was a slip. Not even here where it could have been crucial, after which you never bring...

fontisian wrote: ↑Tue Dec 12, 2023 9:12 pm

boomfrog wrote: ↑Tue Dec 12, 2023 9:05 pm

fontisian wrote: ↑Tue Dec 12, 2023 9:02 pm Boom, why do you think Vig shot Mak and not Fred?

Because who would possibly shoot Fred? He seemed pretty obv town and that was confirmed by several players.

I thought Mak was way townier than Fred.

I have opinions but I can't see how this does anything but help hunt the vig...

Yes...? More wagons D1 means more to analyze. Swerving a wagon at someone is one of the best ways to see real actions and reveal real preferences. Except if you're swerving and accidentally cause a misyeet because people post at the same time and hammer. Moving a wagon onto someone who you do not w...

fontisian wrote: ↑Tue Dec 12, 2023 9:02 pm Boom, why do you think Vig shot Mak and not Fred?

Because who would possibly shoot Fred? He seemed pretty obv town and that was confirmed by several players.

I agree with this analysis. How do you reconcile that with your conviction that scum's plan for today is to get the Vengeful yeeted? Don't you think that a Boom+fonti+x team also would have thought of that? Also, if you are convinced that Boom is Vengeful why are you stating that you would vote fon...

@madge: Why did you say your be ready to move your vote at EoD1 but then didn't help finalize the yeet on Bessie or Wam?

Swiss wrote: ↑Tue Dec 12, 2023 9:07 am

fontisian wrote: ↑Mon Dec 11, 2023 6:50 pm Fucking hell.

This I like

Why?

My D1 town reads were good. Dislike Town Freddino - town slipped repeatedly Makhaira - I think the cumulative slips add up to sincere. Sabrar- good analysis, giving away a lot of town clears. bessie - town slip is likely real. Only scum with fonti or seven. Seven - giving out the Mak town clear was...

That is not why I voted wam. I voted him because he'd not been notably townie. His D0 analysis wasn't scummy but it was unfortunately NAI, therefore I found no reason not to choose him to yeet. Most people in the game had been notably townie in some way with a few exceptions, and wam was the only o...

We shouldn't be worried about hitting vengeful. We only needed to avoid them in a 3v2. Getting rid of them is good because it avoids that potential scenario from happening. I agree with this analysis. How do you reconcile that with your conviction that scum's plan for today is to get the Vengeful y...

alright yeah fine we have no time Unvote: JC Vote: Bessie JC doesnt go to endgame if I die promise me that So sworn. If I die, don't tunnel him. This is Frozen telling me to not let scum!JC win, if he dies and I live. That's a. Not a scenario I was really expecting to happen and b. Something I will...

fontisian wrote: ↑Tue Dec 12, 2023 3:22 am You called me certain scum right out the gate, and now you're acting like I overreacted.

boomfrog wrote: ↑Mon Dec 11, 2023 3:10 pm Fonti is almost certainly scum.

But whatever. You've already committed. If we are both town we've already lost.