New XKCD Forums

boomfrog

Well if Vic isn't scum here I'm comfortable blaming him for the loss. If LaserGuy is also scum he's played this perfectly. Actually there's only one thing that makes me hesitate. @LaserGuy why did you not actually vote for no lynch? For the record, I'm an instant resurrectionist. Effectively a docto...

boomfrog

If there is a Mafia they have to have a way to deal with multiple doctors. If there's a SK then the second scum has to be very anti town as well. The only other combo I could see is SK + Arsonist. If I can convince you there is a Mafia would you accept that Vicarn must be on the Mafia team and vote ...

boomfrog

Vicarin wrote: ↑Thu Nov 03, 2022 8:57 pm You going to vote for me then boomfrog? Why post all that and then not actually follow through with a vote?

Seriously, what did you think I was saying that you would think I should slap down a vote?

boomfrog

But I do now realize Bessie can't be mafia with you or LG cause she would have voted to end the game already.

boomfrog

Vicarin wrote: ↑Thu Nov 03, 2022 8:57 pm You going to vote for me then boomfrog? Why post all that and then not actually follow through with a vote?

Interesting that you just skimmed my logic and then glanced at the end instead of actually reading what I wrote. Hmm.

boomfrog

@Laserguy help me understand what you like about Vicarin's entrance This post is not made by a Heury-Vicarin scummate. This is sincere confusion. That means either Bessie or LG are scum or there is not a 2-person scum team. I'm getting a very townie read of Bessie from the way she is scum reading m...

boomfrog

@Vicarin, glad to have you in the game mate. Thanks for subbing in. You've pre-answered all my questions I would have had. When you were only spectating what did you think was going on with all the spec setup oblique talk?

boomfrog

I've had a very difficult day today and yesterday in RL. So for the record I was mostly not lurking. I did read your post and almost gave an off the cuff reply but the desire to include a link caused me to delay and I haven't had RL time to get to it until now. Anyway, the post I was thinking of was...

boomfrog

@LaserGuy: Who should we eliminate first?

boomfrog

It was this post. But I'm confused why Bessie is confused about my understanding. But I guess I'll let that drop.

I don't think coordinating helps. The Mafia must have some tool to use against us. I think we all know the roughly best plan.

boomfrog

I have a theory but I want to hear your explanation. When you made this post did you currently scum read Seven? If yes what did you think you were catching him on? I was currently scum reading Seven when I made that post. I didn’t think I was catching him on anything in particular. I was deliberate...

boomfrog

I'm working on reads tonight but FYI I'm struggling for time for this game and have asked for a replacement if one can be found. Understandable, thanks for hanging in there. I think I can save you some time and just ask the most important question. What do you think of the below post and what do yo...

boomfrog

Maybe a protective role that can protect against one of the Mafia but not they other? Since we're talking about setup anyway, I'd be interested in hearing a bit more about what you are thinking regarding this. I was thinking maybe the Mafia each have a specific way to kill and maybe a psychic docto...

boomfrog

Halloween 2022

Spoiler (Show/Hide)

The setup is oops all doctors!

What a perfect balance between Sabrar and Madge mod style.

So probably anyone who didn't put resistance at max became scum.

Was the original plan to make whatever the minority stat choice was into scum? Nice.

boomfrog

@LaserGuy: Do you have a strong suspicion of what the setup is? Is your scum read of Heury based on that setup theory?

boomfrog

Besides our convo, I'm waiting for Wam's reads.

boomfrog

Wait a second, bessie might be mafia here now that I think about it. You're reminding me of the last Halloween game. Town bessie generally has a read on me that hovers around null. Last Halloween game though you were scum reading me. Though considering that scum are probably solo in this game, I th...

boomfrog

I was your scummiest read yesterday. And I was completely wrong about my two main scum reads. Yet today you are perfectly willing to honor my request, without question. Why aren’t you questioning me? First of all, I'm always happy to entertain strange requests unless I think they are helpful to scu...

boomfrog

That wasn't supposed to be bold, sorry.

boomfrog

heuristically_alone wrote: ↑Sat Oct 29, 2022 11:10 pm Vote: Laserguy

Ninja'd but you should probably unvote.

boomfrog

Psychic seems to be a cop variant or a rule that can talk to the dead. Neither make sense here. Maybe a protective role that can protect against one of the Mafia but not they other? Speaking of which, we are most likely at ElLo (formerly known as LYLO). So no one should vote unless they are ready to...

boomfrog

FYI, I'm going to drop the whole opposite day thing. Shenanigans are for D1.

bessie wrote: ↑Sat Oct 29, 2022 10:19 pmBefore BoomFrog gives us his updated list.

Oh, what a me style request. I'm intrigued but I will wait patiently for Wam's reply.

boomfrog

Halloween 2022 First of all, flavor is on point. Thank you Madge and Sabrar for running this. Now... who to kill, who to kill... Heury is the most obv town and will be un-missyeet-able. He also has a tendency to suspect me and he sticks to his guns and is not easily bamboozled by shenanigans. LaserG...

boomfrog

If LaserGuy actually believed what he said he'd have voted Wam to protect Bessie.

boomfrog

bessie wrote: ↑Thu Oct 27, 2022 5:13 am I will be in my car driving soon and might not be home before deadline if anyone wants to ask me anything it needs to be now.

Will you vote Wam in order to survive the Day?

New XKCD Forums

Search found 663 matches

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Gojoe Memorial Mafia Thread

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Gojoe Memorial Mafia Thread

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)

Re: Stranger Things Mafia (Halloween 2022)