New XKCD Forums

but like, moody/LG, d1, etc. Sabrar is the obvious doc target, right? There's a joke here that Sabrar is always killed N1. to me it seems like he's the most likely doc target from members of the xkcdcore. I am indeed the super obvious doc-target after Seven specifically brings up the above mentione...

Swiss wrote: ↑Mon Dec 11, 2023 11:19 amI thought he appeared townie yesterDay by forcing an elim and not caring on who.

This is weak reasoning. Scum also doesn't care if all wagons are town.

fontisian wrote: ↑Mon Dec 11, 2023 6:21 pmAssuming moody even made a choice.

Sure, but you're making a lot of assumptions for your case.

fontisian wrote: ↑Mon Dec 11, 2023 5:37 pm If I replaced into a weak doc slot and had no time to form reads, I'd protect a friend who I think is a strong town player.

Not with weak doc. If you really have no time to re-read then you stick with the choice your slot made before the replacement.

Here is my summary of eod, you can let me know if I missed anything. - boomfrog starts the wagon on wam - bessie is 2nd, association - moody is 3rd, self-preservation. - boomfrog limits the choice to wam or moody. - JC is 4th wam and moody now both have 4 votes - fonti votes for moody - Makhaira vot...

Seven wrote: ↑Sun Aug 27, 2023 3:13 amYou are a Vengeful Mafiate. If you are ever eliminated by town vote at any point in the game, the Mafia faction receives an additional kill that night. Note that the kill has to be used immediately; it can't be saved up and used later.

Why are people still misreading rules??

PYP

Spoiler (Show/Hide)

Thanks LaserGuy for subbing in

LaserGuy replaced in at the worst possible moment as now we have no idea who he targeted.
The whole situation would be hilarious except it's sad. Time to reread.

PYP

Spoiler (Show/Hide)

Town!me is complaining about the length of the night and how I will now surely die because they yeeted my Doc.

PYP

Spoiler (Show/Hide)

I read the end of the day in order and didn't skip ahead to the yeet-result. So imagine my surprise when wam claimed Cop. I was like 'WTF is he doing???'

[1] That's incorrect. [2] Please elaborate on the Madge connection. Do you not think you will be dying tonight for some reason? [3] What's weird about it? It's weird that Swiss thinks it's weird. [4] I didn't lie. [1] Maybe it's a bit of an exaggeration but you come off like that. [2] I think one o...

bessie : she has a consistent playstyle that is easily recreatable as scum. I question both moody's read of +4 and wam's vote for not being towny enough. I generally would not vote for her D1, I believe scum!bessie can be most easily caught on later days due to connections. boomfrog : certainly did...

Swiss wrote: ↑Thu Dec 07, 2023 10:24 amIf my timezones are correct deadline in 7 hoursish

Not sure how you can get the timezone wrong when there is a link to a countdown clock in every votecount.
I'll be back in the evening to place a vote, deadline is 6am for me so unlikely that I'll be around.

Hmm, I remember thinking about clarifying and deciding not to. I don't remember now why, sorry. My disappointment is immeasurable. He hasn't given the reasoning for his recent vote, Yes, and that came after he retracted his suspicion on bessie. We still have no clue what he's thinking despite earli...

@Seven, swiss and fonti and anyone else who asked me about this, Did you *not* get anything out of it? I thought my reasons where pretty clear to anyone on S team which is why I didn't care about their answers. I can think of at least 4 perfectly normal reasons off the top of my head why you would ...

Explain it to me as if I were an idiot As fonti said scum already has access to at least one 'safe' claim, maybe two. That's why claims cannot be trusted because if someone claims e.g. Doc then we cannot be sure if that role is actually in the game. The only way to potentially verify or refute such...

Swiss wrote: ↑Wed Dec 06, 2023 5:22 pmThat's moot because any claim is not to be trusted in this set up.

It's exactly because claims cannot be trusted that this is not moot.

Sabrar wrote: ↑Tue Dec 05, 2023 12:12 pmWith that said I think I found a potential town-slip by wam.

Don't want to leave this for D2. I think wam's approach to fake-claiming here does not come from a scum pov due to the nature of the setup.

Now I get Swiss' anger at the forum software.

Makhaira wrote: ↑Wed Dec 06, 2023 4:10 amSab feels off

Your last comment about me prior to that was a scumlean on me because not voting D0, days ago. You have avoided reacting to my reply. Can you now elaborate?

Seven wrote: ↑Wed Dec 06, 2023 8:20 amFrozen (Mak) is town.

I agree that your interpretation is likely right if Mak's initial confusion was not faked.

PYP

Spoiler (Show/Hide)

Can we please have next time a game where half of Town doesn't get cleared D1 because they haven't read the rules of the game they signed up for???

@Swiss Who would you choose as a Masonizer partner? Who would you choose as a Vigilante night kill? Who would you protect as a Doc, and would that be the same as a Weak Doc? Who would you investigate as a Cop? Can we not do this? People posting their hypothetical targets only helps Town in case a W...

Interesting. I think my view of the math part is the same across ganes, regardless of my alignment, because it's actually complimentary with scum thoughts on misyeets. I think this is a poor reason to townread me. Obviously you know your own mind better, I don't think this topic ever came up previo...

With that said I think I found a potential town-slip by wam. This sucks.