New XKCD Forums

boomfrog wrote: ↑Fri Feb 04, 2022 8:18 pm

Spoiler (Show/Hide)

I really want to know what Osie's "oof" at EoD1 meant...

Spoiler (Show/Hide)

Pre-flip association in the way you did can be used to set up a dichotomy.

The Snide Sniper wrote: ↑Mon Feb 14, 2022 10:00 pm THE CATGIRL CLUTCH!! That was my role! When I saw that result I was like "oh my god the catgirl actually did something!"

Good game, truly. Frankly, it's hilarious that the catgirl actually did something meaningful.

Yeah that was me.

*Phew*

GG.

Thoughts to come.

WMU, you had my submission; it sounds like Wam didn't quite handle it correctly, but oh well.

Secret Santa

Spoiler (Show/Hide)

Hopefully one of the worst or Madge is also town and also votes for WMU. There's no way she's town here. That claim was just painful. I guess we'll see whenever they're up.

xX_WakeMeUp1337_Xx wrote: ↑Mon Feb 14, 2022 8:22 pmYou don't know how the role works. That's a lie.

Remember the setup. Of course I know how the role works.

xX_WakeMeUp1337_Xx wrote: ↑Mon Feb 14, 2022 8:22 pmYou talk about alien stuff but i never mentioned that, you invent things.

An Alien is a type of Jailkeeper.

I think between my reads and Boom's, I was still leaning Sniper first and foremost. I'm thinking the team is Sniper+WMU due in part to poor claims. The way that WMU suggested that I should specifically have been targeted by an Alien role implies that she has knowledge of an Alien role in addition to...

I'm pretty sure I know how WMU's role works and what she's described is impossible... Sniper still looks the most sus, but WMU's claim is pretty bad. I kinda like Madge's claim and following behaviour. Why is Sniper sus? Because of gamestate (Scum likely sitting back), positioning posts, and workin...

I would assume I wouldn't learn of being (standardly) roleblocked, since I get no feedback from my action. So either my role didn't work (including redirection/the worst being hidden by someone else) or the worst is lying. I think you would learn of being roleblocked but not redirected. It's possib...

My role gives gifts for dead or alive. I understood wrong that i will receive something from the targeted player role and N1 I targeted Moody with a gift. I received the same gift back N2. I targeted Osie last night and my action failed. Because of what i received, i wasn't RBed. But for the action...

Heading to bed but hm.

I think I'm comfortable with voting TSS some time once I'm awake.

Though if Worst wasn't notified of a visit and Madge wasn't notified of a roleblock...

I'm pretty sure I know how WMU's role works and what she's described is impossible...

Sniper still looks the most sus, but WMU's claim is pretty bad.

I kinda like Madge's claim and following behaviour.

So i am alive because I had bad reads and votes. That doesn't mean I am scum, that means I am pocketed by scum and I have wrong reads. Now thinking at day 1, Osie used his meta knowledge to tell me the worst is villager. After so many flips and after the worst who wasn't suspected by others except ...

My role gives gifts for dead or alive. I understood wrong that i will receive something from the targeted player role and N1 I targeted Moody with a gift. I received the same gift back N2. I targeted Osie last night and my action failed. Because of what i received, i wasn't RBed. But for the action...

xX_WakeMeUp1337_Xx wrote: ↑Mon Feb 14, 2022 5:56 amBut for the action on you to fail, my friend Osie, that means you were something like jailkept so your own action couldn't go through.

I am slightly confused by mechs so I let this here to be interpreted if I am wrong, but I think Osie lied

I did not get any notification of my actions failing.

I'm leaning towards voting for Sniper.

Hmm. This is frustratingly convenient due to my action usage this game, since Madge could still have a killing role and be claiming otherwise. I'm a doctor with a single-use self-protect. I self-protected on Night 1 in fear of Bessie killing me, and then protected the worst on Night 2 since they fit...

madge wrote: ↑Mon Feb 14, 2022 1:22 amI have *NOT* claimed JOAT. I have claimed that I visited Osie N1 and did nothing harmful.

And Bessie claimed to have seen your visit.

What did you do?

Secret Santa Hmm. I'm waiting for some kind of sign of life... WMU and the worst both look good, so maybe I'm just spot on the money on Madge+Sniper. I feel like bessie had one specific way that she expected people to play so because of me not fitting into that bubble by ignoring her FoS (still not ...

I think I might have found something here. This series of posts bugs me. Osie: too much fire and fury to be worth doing my head in about. has had enough rope to either be helpful as town / self-incriminate as scum. we will look at the rope situation toMorrow. So Madge, why'd you visit Osie last nigh...

the worst wrote: ↑Sun Feb 13, 2022 9:24 pmI'd fairly strongly encourage massclaiming first.

What does massclaiming give us in this case? All the roles were player-submitted; there's no rhyme or reason to them.

The Snide Sniper wrote: ↑Sun Feb 13, 2022 8:17 pm Well, I thought I had caught bessie's killer but it just told me "a catgirl".

Wat?

IDK, Sniper's posts look pretty bad in retrospect and WMU and worst have both been much more solid...

Secret Santa: I'm guessing that either Bessie or Moody had the role I submitted. I didn't get to see anything from it. Oh well. It's a shame that scum killed Bessie so soon after she had started to be more civil. I'm pretty sure the fact that Boom and Bessie were the kills points to Madge though. My...

Okay, so bessie flipping as town supports my earlier theory that scum have been sitting back and letting us tear each other apart. That said, I am concerned that both WMU and the worst have survived to XyLO. I'm also more and more convinced that Madge is scum given that all of the kills have been pe...