New XKCD Forums

Makhaira

For your other question, if you're starting from the standpoint that everyone looks townie start of D1, then you would go with the most charitable interpretation and work from there. That's part of the reason I use Cynical View, because he starts from the opposite side and it lets me contrast the t...

Makhaira

I very seriously think that the various slots saying Im scummy for suggesting an early claim from fred are having an outsized reaction to that suggestion. The loss of a PR in this setup for town is relatively low impact, this is not a PR heavy or PR centralized game and experience players should be ...

Makhaira

Author order explained in Seven's post here . bessie came up first with being suspicious of heury, and since I always default to her as town, you looked to be glomming on to that goodwill. It turns out that your post I'm citing in this came ~10 hours after hers, but I'm still willing to entertain t...

Makhaira

AdumbroDeus wrote: ↑Tue Aug 15, 2023 8:27 am Oh ya, now I REALLY want Makhaira dead after finding out he's FF. Sorry dude, but that post stinks to high heaven coming from a player with that much experience.

Literally what about my post stinks to high heaven and is inexcusable for an experienced player from your perspective?

Makhaira

are you saying you think my question to heury was attempted buddying? and when you say "him" who are you talking about, me or heury? a. At the time I thought your suspicion of heury was a secondary reaction not a primary one, but that may be an artifact of reading the posts in author orde...

Makhaira

Mak - also suspicious of heury (Cynical View says buddying, but I'm not listening to him yet) +1 are you saying you think my question to heury was attempted buddying? and when you say "him" who are you talking about, me or heury? why did you think you would die N0? There are only 11 livin...

Makhaira

Vote: freddino

Makhaira

Im blaming phoneposting for botching that bold tag

Makhaira

heuristically_alone wrote: ↑Thu Aug 10, 2023 6:48 pm Ooo I'm still alive. That's a positive start

VOTE: somi

why did you think you would die N0?

Vote: Adumbrodeus

Havent been able to do that in wayyyyy too long

Makhaira

Makhaira

bessie let me know if theres anything else you want from me like Im not trying to muddy the waters I think my solve and rationale for it are very clear but happy to expand on anything you think should be considered Nothing really. My reread convinced me of what I have believed since Day 1, that you...

Makhaira

This is just throwing shade. If i'm not lying then by definition it can't be an 'excuse', let alone a lame one. its not throwing shade, you're just missing the point. removing intentionality from any in-game action in this way is fundamentally lame in the sense that ever arguing in the vein of &quo...

Makhaira

I think Sabrars position here is predicatable and he's taking as reasonable of an approach as he can, can totally respect that I too have a very hard time seeing any world where bessie is scum. obviously my slot comes with the inherent issues of being a late game replacement for a low content slot b...

Makhaira

Im here till deadline @bessie @freddie, sounds like we're on the same page re: madge but if theres anything else you want me to consider nows the time

Makhaira

Sabrar wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 4:57 am I'm here, going to address a couple of things tomorrow if we're still around. Just want to get this out:

https://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/t ... nt=cursive

Deadline is in like 35 minutes btw, your post makes it sound like you think its tomorrow

Makhaira

I'm fairly certain Madge is mafia. I think either Sabrar or Bessie is the millerizer. If Bessie is not millerizer she is likely town. If Sabrar is not millerizer he is likely the other mafia. At the end d1 I was playing with the idea of Bessie as Madge's scum partner but right now I think that's le...

Makhaira

some initial light distancing im perceiving followed by a flip on sabrar from thinking heury was light scum to a town read seemingly out of no where. Incorrect, I never had a 'light scum' read on heury. If you're referring to this then that was a joke (which can be deduced even by players unfamilia...

Makhaira

ok just started D2 and lol answered my own question, ok so somi was cop, got a guilty on heury who was then elim'd, and then somi got NK'd, so the power moved to a random universal backup still living, who based on current claims and lack of counterclaims, seems to be fred Im assuming the backup tha...

Makhaira

I didn't see any cop claim D1, if anyone claimed cop after EOD1 and claimed any investigation results reposting them here would be helpful basically we don't know if heury was godfather or not right? we kind of have to assume that millerizer wins tomorrow if fred is telling the truth about inheritin...

Makhaira

should be able to finish the rest of the game by tonight but im going to be pretty busy for the next few hours so may end up finishing the read tonight and posting full thoughts in the morning depending on how tired I am

Makhaira

Ok Im over halfway done, made it thru all of day one, thoughts so far Weird early interactions between Sabrar and Heury, some initial light distancing im perceiving followed by a flip on sabrar from thinking heury was light scum to a town read seemingly out of no where. they seem to be interacting s...

Makhaira

Do we know if millerizer targets are notified if they are targeted? Or if only targets that arent immune or millers by default get notified while immune roles/default millers would not? Or if no one is notified in any capacity as to millerizer targeting?

And has anyone made any other PR claims?

Makhaira

Ok game is a little denser than I thought, couldnt get thru a full catchup read but I atleast went thru the setup So theres 5 of us comprised of 3 factions, 1 millerizer, 1 mafia, 3 town. One of the three town must be the original cop because no one else has flipped cop. If and when the cop dies, as...

Makhaira

Hey everyone, just saw that im replacing in today, ill try to get caught up tonight

Makhaira

Sorry forgot to update the list

Players
1. Heury
2. Wam
3. bessie
4. Makhaira
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.

bessie wrote: ↑Sun Jul 17, 2022 1:37 am Hi Makhaira, good to see you!

Thanks, you too! =)

New XKCD Forums

Search found 334 matches

Re: Sorcerer's 11 Mafia - xkcd edition - Day 1

Re: Sorcerer's 11 Mafia - xkcd edition - Day 1

Re: Sorcerer's 11 Mafia - xkcd edition - Day 1

Re: Sorcerer's 11 Mafia - xkcd edition - Day 1

Re: Sorcerer's 11 Mafia - xkcd edition - Day 1

Re: Sorcerer's 11 Mafia - xkcd edition - Day 1

Re: Sorcerer's 11 Mafia - xkcd edition - Day 1

Re: Sorcerer's 11 Mafia - xkcd edition - Day 1*

Re: Sorcerer's 11 Mafia - xkcd edition - Day 1*

Re: A Mafia Game: Setup TBA

Re: Millerizer Mafia - Day 4

Re: Millerizer Mafia - Day 4

Re: Millerizer Mafia - Day 4

Re: Millerizer Mafia - Day 3

Re: Millerizer Mafia - Day 3

Re: Millerizer Mafia - Day 2

Re: Millerizer Mafia - Day 3

Re: Millerizer Mafia - Day 3

Re: Millerizer Mafia - Day 3

Re: Millerizer Mafia - Day 3

Re: Millerizer Mafia - Day 3

Re: Millerizer Mafia - Day 3

Re: Millerizer Mafia - Day 3

Re: Millerizer Mafia - Day 3

Re: Recyclables Mafia