New XKCD Forums

Secret Santa Uggh, I just don't care much about this game any more... It's so exhausting, scum is clearly flying under the radar, and bessie's gone as far as to accuse me of cryptography now. Maybe WMU is scum? GSA suggests Madge+Sniper but I could see one of WMU or the worst controlling things. May...

madge wrote: ↑Fri Feb 11, 2022 6:34 am

bessie wrote: ↑Fri Feb 11, 2022 6:05 am So Madge, why'd you visit Osie last night?

to prove that i didn't kill him

Looking back at that post, the game I think the worst was talking about is the first I played with the worst, which was not an enjoyable game for IRL reasons. Also the worst was being a bit of a doofus in that game but it worked out well for him.

The only thing that's odd @osieorb18 : you didn't link me the scum game (or I didn't notice it?) As far as I can recall, I haven't rolled scum since this game outside of Russian Roulette games in Live Mafia, but maybe the smashboards game in which I didn't really do anything was more recent. Oh, I ...

EFoT = Elim First on Tie

This game uses "hard majority" majority elimination at greater than 50% of living players during the Day and elimination at the end of the Day for the player with the most votes. Ties will be resolved by checking who received that number of votes first.

My entire set of current scum worlds voting together only feels like it confirms my theory.

It's EFoT and only the person who would be the second of the wagons is self-preserving... I don't get it.

Meh.

(Tonight IRL not this Night phase)

I'mma dive Madge tonight and see what I find.

Okay so hot take: GSA suggests that at least one scum should be within Heury/Madge/Sniper, as scum have likely been sitting back and watching town tear themselves apart. Heury is the most likely of those three. I hate to say it since their play is openly less townie than the vast majority of play I'...

Heury's posting talks about boomfrog like he knows he's flipped town but then forgets about moody being flipped town. Dont really care if it's sincere mistake or trying to trick us - we'll never know. Someone who's subconsciously aware of who was the scum nightkill but not aware of who was the town...

the worst wrote: ↑Wed Feb 09, 2022 8:45 pm Mm this is by no means comprehensive

Oh for sure.

heuristically_alone wrote: ↑Wed Feb 09, 2022 8:14 pm

the worst wrote: ↑Fri Feb 04, 2022 12:31 am ugh. maybe anyway. I'm just deliberating and realising boomfrog/moody are the only ones who seem to be processing and trying to solve.

If this is worst!scum, could moody be a teammate? I am slightly leaning town on moody though.

Moody was the Day 1 elimination.

Whatever, but please read my comment immediately preceding this one regarding Osie’s buddying on Madge and think about if you agree. This post is the one of yours closest preceeding the Oracle Boomfrog post, and the only thing I saw like what you're talking about was Osie saying Madge is a better p...

Wow, I speak English.

"I'll wait 24 and a bit hours for at least Madge 'to have had the chance to post' some analysis first.

I have a hot take on the gamestate, but I'll wait 24 and a bit hours for at least Madge has posted some analysis first.

Analyzing (or talking about) confirmation posts FoS players for town claims and “would I do this as scum” posts Post-by-post analysis Behavioural analysis. Passive aggressive questioning of others Self meta-ing Not analysis tools if you don't follow through. Ask someone that hasn’t played in a whil...

There are also other reasons but I have to reread the day 1 for them. While there, can you let me know your thoughts on Heury? contrarily, I'm quite cold on scum!wmu vote: madge I don't understand you at all. Say it again for me like I am 5 pls I think you're town. Same with you. I'm confident enou...

madge wrote: ↑Wed Feb 09, 2022 3:49 ami am not going to do reads outside of pocketing dead townies and vote analysis. vote analysis is not happening todday. maybe tomorrow.

You mean tomorrow IRL or toMorrow in game?

Welp you don’t seem to be considering very hard, since once again, all your posts so far today are about me me me. That's just not remotely true. If you're town, then a good step to showing it would be sharing an organic analysis of madge and/or heury, as someone with more experience interacting wi...

Same with you. You are not going to point to BoomFrog on Day 3 and blame my elimination on him. Give your own reasons, preferably reasons that don’t contradict your Day 1 content. And before you auto-attack me for “distancing” or “not posting in good faith” I refer you to your own analysis in this ...

The Snide Sniper wrote: ↑Mon Feb 07, 2022 8:01 pm I'm not sure why the wagon switched from you/bessie to moody, but that's mainly because I'm too lazy to read through 5 pages of posts.

I think there was a general agreement that moody was the scummiest.

This Day, I'm pretty much at Bessie/Madge/Heury in roughly that order of preference.

The Snide Sniper wrote: ↑Mon Feb 07, 2022 7:49 pm So I wanted to vote "no elim" D1 on principle, but apparently voting "no elim" is incredibly off-meta, so I'll be voting for Bessie. I also wanted to say this D1 but missed the deadline by a couple hours.

Vote: bessie

Any thoughts to add on what's happened so far?

Unvote to avoid possibility of quick-hammer.

And now to get back to not being on my computer before exercise in the morning.