New XKCD Forums

unvote

Waiting a counter claim

There is confirmation bias but dont think that's scummy in this case. Could you elaborate and go into your read on Wisp? @wam Sorry missed that. Wisp read is on tone and seems to be going for the solve. I think the scummyness comes from the quantity of posts meaning there is always going to be some...

Ebwop when voted as town than scum.

Meta reasons bessie used to be much more aggressive and omgus ish when town than scum. Dont know if it still holds but her response was town meta to me.

Reason I don't know if it holds is I have mentioned it to bessie in other games so she maybe able to fake it these days.

I should be around at deadline but maybe driving. Given the lack of any counter wagon though I'm not expecting much movement.

Morgan wrote: ↑Mon Nov 22, 2021 7:02 pm The case doesn't do anything for me. If anything, your case looks spun to come to a pre-determined conclusion.

But Wisp says you're town, so oh well.

There is confirmation bias but dont think that's scummy in this case.

Wisp wrote: ↑Mon Nov 22, 2021 6:02 pm Lmao a wolf slip, haven't seen one of those in ages
Rip

?

Wisp wrote: ↑Mon Nov 22, 2021 2:31 pm Ya this game is going to be fun to solve at this rate...

Aren't they all?

@sabrar I felt like answering the question why shouldn't I? Dont like sabrar content so far seems very sitting back and not involed which i remember. For once I'm not finding seven suspicious which makes a change. I'm sure it will change soon though. I think jedi is scum due to not wanting to solve ...

Morgan wrote: ↑Sat Nov 20, 2021 3:10 pm Wam, what is my alignment?

Busy but wanted to answer, neutral leaning Town. Not seen anything strongly either way but asking this gives some weak town points

I looked at Halloween mafia a bit, I was checking out Moody's iso there. I think on a shallow level they are about the same, so ya I'm not at all interested in that slot anymore. I think it was just a little bit of disliking his numbers without explaining why they existed. And in Halloween mafia, h...

SuperJedi224 wrote: ↑Fri Nov 19, 2021 3:59 pm Ok there was a lot posted since the last time I got a chance to read this

It is looking like one of suzaku/bessie/wisp right now but we still really don't know much for certain

Why limit yourself to those others are already pushing?

Wisp wrote: ↑Thu Nov 18, 2021 7:27 pm @suzaku
How common is it for you to make a read list like that, relatively early into the game?

From gut I wouldnt say it's out of the ordinary

unvote

vote bessie

3. madge 5. Wam 6. bessie 9. the worst Sabrar So I know for a fact i played with the bottom 3, I think I played with the top two? if Im missing anyone, sorry also whats with all the smash players on this site? Yes I think 1 game on smashboards. For background I had been playing on the old xkcd site...

vote sabrar

Some traditions cant be ignored.

13p Role Madness Mafia Interest/Signups Hi y'all. New to these forums but with hearing about the community revival, I figured there might be more interest here than on Smashboards for a 13p role madness game. The game would likely start no earlier than November 16th, with role PMs sent out a day or...

Great game thank you mods. Moody we got so close!

@seven in mafia chat we debated bussing hard and recruiting but the opportunity never came up. It was also harder to use early game as moody had to be out he game.

Halloween

Spoiler (Show/Hide)

jimbob has worked out that he is probably the only recruitable townie left. As I bet seven is not and zenni knows this. So jimbob is playing for a win as cult recruit. Or jimbob think he is unrecrutiable as well and is banking on it.

Halloween 2021

Spoiler (Show/Hide)

Its annoying to be dead and unable to read spoilers

Not sure what rez powers are left but somehow feel I wont be rezzed

Edit I do have Phoenix in my role name is an inherent rez I dont know about too much too hope for?

I'm back! I'm 99%tss/zenni were the cult leader. They were clearly trying to use unsuccessful recruits as a cop so that makes seven unrecrutiable. Which means that either they are mafia or for balance reasons the mods disnt want an extra kill going to the cult. Rapid reads wise I'm at Town Laser -ca...

I'm going to sleep but consider my vote on seven if it wasnt hamer

LaserGuy wrote: ↑Tue Oct 26, 2021 4:08 pm @Madge: Can we get a prod on Wam? I don't think he's posted at all this phase.

I'm here. As stated previously I was going to be away sat to Tuesday. I'm catching up but I don't think I'm going to be fully up to speed before deadline as I need to sleep!

Busy evening for me. Unless I cant sleep this will be my last post today.

Dont think somi is the right choice. I believe snides claim. Would much prefer seven over somi.

Got distracted halfway through then got ninjad by moody.

The Snide Sniper wrote: ↑Thu Oct 21, 2021 2:30 pm I'd vote for Seven, but was told L-1 is bad.

At this stage it's a lot less bad as long as you state that we are at L-1. Also all mafia communities have different views on this. That's a debate for another day though.

But as long as your around close to deadline knowing your position is enough.