New XKCD Forums

Only mention I can find of "twilight" in the rules: 5. For fairness reasons due to us having lives, players are entitled to send the mods trigger conditions for day abilities. For pace of game reasons, players with twilight abilities are required to send me trigger conditions to use their ...

adum your flip post reads 4 votes on bessie when it should be 5 just heads up you have 5 names there

this flip gives us more info than anything I think and a scum flip paves the path to a very controlled endgame

someone needs to hammer bessie or yall throwin

Seven wrote: ↑Fri Sep 20, 2024 3:34 am We elim Fred. If he's telling the truth, BESSIE HAS TO BE SCUM. I outlined this in my big post, read it. If he's lying, we hit a scummer. Because townies never lie.

hit bessie first then wtf? how is this your EoD pivot putting the whole game in freds hands youre insane

let scum waste NK on fred like holy shit please

sorry I ran out of time guys to do as deep a read as I wanted but I think by rough POE it has to be bessie/JC/moody I can't really see other solves rn

if its wam/seven/thea we already lost

We do not yeet fred here with that claim thats crazy talk

My possible worlds are substantially narrowing by the way, I just have a few more slots to review to complete my PoE, I should be able to get some more substance up on about 6-7 hours and then I will be available until deadline to respond to live going ons but I won't have the ability to do serious ...

@THEA @SEVEN Kind of disappointed yall didn't catch my trick in the wam quotes post. If I told you I intentionally manipulated the quote order in my post to make it look like they were posted in temporal order but they were in fact in reverse order, what do you think I was getting at about Wams play...

@Seven do you legitimately believe it would be dishonorable to truthfully tell the other players that one was experiencing a serious life event that impacts their ability to be present at crucial game moments as scum, but that doing so as town is completely fine? Relatedly, do you believe somi seek...

Wam and Seven's claims directly contradict each other. No way both can be telling the truth. I can verify Wam at least is telling the truth about his result on me. Based on this , Seven seemed to know that Wam had a result on him, and doesn't seem to be pushing back against Wam contradicting him, s...

bolded is clearly typod, which side are you saying you are elite at and which are you saying is "good" but damaged by "how common it is to fear monger [you]" Oops sorry I skill issued my phrasing. Elite wolf game is what I meant to say An example would be last champs semis this ...

@Seven do you legitimately believe it would be dishonorable to truthfully tell the other players that one was experiencing a serious life event that impacts their ability to be present at crucial game moments as scum, but that doing so as town is completely fine? Relatedly, do you believe somi seeki...

moody is weirdly non-committal and like pre making excuses for inactivity at a crucial time ugh JCs activity surge makes my blood run cold freddino is exceptionally good at fake self deprecation if hes scum but yeah I still need to know why this isn't seven/bessie wagons only Hi Mak!! Glad to see y...

Is Mak a slot that is scary lategame ? As in, how likely was Mak a fearkill ? (I dont think it wasnt the case, but dont have the meta to be sure and affirm it lol) being real with you, if anyone in this game answered this question with "no" then I would highly doubt their sincerity as arr...

Is Godfather or roles that could mess with an investigative result common here or not? Since I saw mentioned that game was non bastard I wasnt taking them into account but now questioning myself since godfather was mentioned as a possibility wowee do you consider godfather or functional equivalents...

Wam and Seven's claims directly contradict each other. No way both can be telling the truth. I can verify Wam at least is telling the truth about his result on me. Based on this , Seven seemed to know that Wam had a result on him, and doesn't seem to be pushing back against Wam contradicting him, s...

No idea how that smiley got in there, I must have accidentally hit it while touch scrolling on my phone and I didn't see it, don't read into it it was a complete accident

:) The E isn't the reason why I don't believe it to be AtE. enlighten me An appeal to emotion is attempting to sway others by provoking an emotional reaction. Using a word that describes an emotional state is not an emotional appeal in itself. It could be used to make one, however. For example: &quo...

Wam and Seven's claims directly contradict each other. No way both can be telling the truth. I can verify Wam at least is telling the truth about his result on me. Based on this , Seven seemed to know that Wam had a result on him, and doesn't seem to be pushing back against Wam contradicting him, s...

I didn't think of it as AtE. A couple of people said they believed if I had a real result, I would have held onto it instead of outting it immediately. Being excited about the result seems like a reasonable reason I would have failed to do that. do you not consider excitement to be an emotion? The ...

bessie wrote: ↑Sun Sep 15, 2024 4:25 am

Seven wrote: ↑Sun Sep 15, 2024 4:16 am Ha, I have a guilty result on bessie.

Vote: bessie

No, you don't.

Vote: Seven

Bessie please explain the rationale behind this reaction and vote in detail

The motivation was to add credibility to the idea that I had an in-game result on bessie. through fake AtE? faustian bargain I didn't think of it as AtE. A couple of people said they believed if I had a real result, I would have held onto it instead of outting it immediately. Being excited about th...

Is Godfather or roles that could mess with an investigative result common here or not? Since I saw mentioned that game was non bastard I wasnt taking them into account but now questioning myself since godfather was mentioned as a possibility wowee do you consider godfather or functional equivalents...