New XKCD Forums

Wam wrote: ↑Tue Apr 16, 2024 9:36 pm

Makhaira wrote: ↑Tue Apr 16, 2024 9:35 pm

Wam wrote: ↑Tue Apr 16, 2024 8:55 pm If you have any questions for me left today you have about 30 min

if I get elim'd today should I shoot or not and why? And if I were to shoot, who should I shoot?

Don't shoot too high risk.

If I had to shoot, who should I shoot

Tbh every slot in this game should explicitly provide an opinion on whether I should shoot if elim'd, why or why not, and who I should shoot if I were forced to

Using counterevidence to nullify an argument. Argument Premise: Jack wouldn't kill me if he was scum. Premise: I am alive. Conclusion: Jack is scum. Counterargument Jack killed you before when he was scum. Therefore, the first premise is false, and the conclusion is unsound. Jack could be scum but ...

Wam wrote: ↑Tue Apr 16, 2024 8:55 pm If you have any questions for me left today you have about 30 min

if I get elim'd today should I shoot or not and why? And if I were to shoot, who should I shoot?

I literally have evidence that heury would perform better than JC in endgame because Ive seen heury actually scum hunt and produce legitimate solves. JC has literally never done that And no, WIFOM logic is still the same logic, and suffers from the same fallacious traits, whether marshalled affirmat...

That is the definition of a distinction without a difference and you know it There aren't the same. For the record though I don't suss you because of the JC wifom. are youa actually arguing that "WIFOM" arguments are only proper in a defensive posture when responding to accusations from o...

Seven literally stop flipping the question back to me and answer it, you a flagrantly dodging right now and trying to flip the burden back on to me so you dont have to defend your "lol this is just WIFOM" handwaving of my point

I need to reread to see why scum would make that NK, someone must have soul read him as a strong PR or something because I saw the slot entirely as a liability Did you get an answer to this? What do you think of my moody theory? sketchy post here from Wam. Asking me if I answered the question for m...

Also again, using JC's flip as a defense isn't really productive. You haven't commented on the day play aspect I asked you about. So seems like you are dishonest here. I know you like to argue so I feel you would have delved more into this, you are almost as annoying to argue with as Macman, but th...

I still dont feel great about heury but atleast I can trust town!heury in endgame This literally makes no sense as reasoning to switch off someone. Again, what's the basis of this? It comes off to me as someone just finding a place to vote. you cannot tell me with a straight face that you trust tow...

If you think scum!me NKs JC you are legitimately brain dead, the kill more or less kills me. Scum!me keeps JC around as a free slot to manipulate or miselim You're actually one of the few people I think would kill him. You, maybe Wam cause he's chaotic and unpredictable. Best reasoning I could gues...

The more I think about it why would scum!bessie even hammer there in the first place, highly doubt scum!bessie wants to even draw attention to herself by hammering when she knows the only two slots with votes on them are town. That hammer reveals that bessie genuinely preferred one flip to the other...

Vote: heury To prevent a last minute vote switch. Honestly the only post I didnt like from bessie here. If you knew you were posting this a minute before deadline, how realistic is it to fear a wagon swing in the last 60 seconds before deadline? If two people swapped in a coordinated fashion at EOD...

JC_DADDY25 wrote: ↑Wed Apr 10, 2024 3:56 am I am suspicious of Somi, I just didn't feel a strong reason to vote him.

JC knocking the somi slot again

moody7277 wrote: ↑Wed Apr 10, 2024 3:16 am

EGW wrote: ↑Wed Apr 10, 2024 3:11 am

moody7277 wrote: ↑Wed Apr 10, 2024 3:02 am At this point, I am going to wait until 30 minutes before EOD, then vote JC.

Don't you scum read Heury though?

I'm scum reading both of them, but momentum looked like JC was going to be the elim. If we want to do in the wizard, I'm game for that.

Gross af post from moody here

Im getting there im still rereading

So if you're worried about both me and seven you can sort us both this phase by yeeting seven and let the scum sort me for you, else scum are looking at an insanely risky endgame

Its either seven and a passive mate or literally two coaster scum like straight up. We have a much better EV flipping seven here to see if we're in turbo snow land or "scum are just letting active town cannibalize each other" land If seven flips town scum pretty much have to NK me otherwis...

EGW you a making a mistake thinking Im the for sure play at this point idk what to tell you but youre dead wrong thats its me and seven, no idea how you could think my interactions with that slot is scum theater like I do not buss/distance like that

I've read all the way up, like how EGW is pressuring JC. Will be on at EOD, currently not voting because it would either put JC at L-1, heury at L-2, or be a futile wagon. Weird post, you felt it was important to tell us you were all read up but then basically told us nothing about what youve concl...

I don't really see the benefit, but whatever you do, don't do Heury vs me or something like that, it'd just make D1 even more of a waste. I'm probably biased but I think it's better not to include any "ML bait" players in the dome at all, so mafia doesn't have that easy option and we actu...

Town Bessie Wam Mak Seven EGW Heury Moody Somitomi Scum JC, again. How does your reads change on Wam and Somi? If you have no strong feelings, why did you vote Seven while not being serious? What's your angle there? Well, I still feel scumminess from Somi. Wam moves further down the list toward bei...

moody7277 wrote: ↑Tue Apr 09, 2024 11:41 am Or it could be I didn't want a random vote to be part of what was obviously becoming a serious wagon.

Why not?

Before I signed up, I said my posting will be scarce because of a new job and I'd have limited availability. To be clear I'm not scum reading you because of the limited availability. I'm scum reading you as your thought process as shown in the thread doesn't seem to be following any logical process...

Bessie and Somi, I would like to see your reads when you guys can. If y'all have any questions about mine feel free to ask. Ok, snap list because I'm super not sure how much time and energy I'm gonna have later: EGW moody heury bessie Seven <---mystery wrapped in an enigma line wam Makhaira JC No r...