New XKCD Forums

Using counterevidence to nullify an argument. Argument Premise: Jack wouldn't kill me if he was scum. Premise: I am alive. Conclusion: Jack is scum. Counterargument Jack killed you before when he was scum. Therefore, the first premise is false, and the conclusion is unsound. Jack could be scum but ...

That is the definition of a distinction without a difference and you know it There aren't the same. For the record though I don't suss you because of the JC wifom. are youa actually arguing that "WIFOM" arguments are only proper in a defensive posture when responding to accusations from o...

I still dont feel great about heury but atleast I can trust town!heury in endgame This literally makes no sense as reasoning to switch off someone. Again, what's the basis of this? It comes off to me as someone just finding a place to vote. you cannot tell me with a straight face that you trust tow...

Makhaira wrote: ↑Tue Apr 16, 2024 5:48 pm That is the definition of a distinction without a difference and you know it

There aren't the same. For the record though I don't suss you because of the JC wifom.

If you think scum!me NKs JC you are legitimately brain dead, the kill more or less kills me. Scum!me keeps JC around as a free slot to manipulate or miselim You're actually one of the few people I think would kill him. You, maybe Wam cause he's chaotic and unpredictable. Best reasoning I could gues...

I'm not sure I entirely understand why Mak would respond to his own downfall by incriminating his partner. I meant incriminating Bessie, or trying to. Otherwise, what purpose would him voting Bessie initially be? It's certainly not productive. Going after indies at this point, if that alignment eve...

Whispers float through the ancient hall, In cloaks of midnight, they heed the call. Zephyrs carry their chants so wide, Among the stars, their powers glide. Riddles and mysteries, in their hands unfurled, Dancing with magic, a joke of a transaction. You're a WIZARD, Harry. Why did you capitalize wi...

I also find it really, really ironic that seven gave me shit for "WIFOM" arguing that I wouldnt ever NK JC, when seven then turns around and argues they would always NK town!ran for meta reasons, like come tf one blatant rules for thee not for me nonsense There’s a difference. I was using...

Seven https://ramenchef.net/nxf/viewtopic.php?p=64954#p64954 So Seven kind of predicted the day 1 elim in his 1st post. I'm coming back to this https://ramenchef.net/nxf/viewtopic.php?p=64971#p64971 at the end and thos one https://ramenchef.net/nxf/viewtopic.php?p=65134#p65134 and this https://rame...

Ranmaru's pet Iguana's Game Winning Reads Z25 : Used grandma's irl illness to avoid being yeeted. Scum lean. Yondu : He may have been your father, boy. But he wasn't your daddy. Strong town. Xivii : Posted chat logs with several different players that seemed to be from a scum chat. Scum slip? I thi...

Word. btw Ran, have you played with the player Arogame? You guys are so much alike, it would be funny to see the two of you in a game.

I wasn't scumreading you D1 for it to matter. That is a good point that you have considered me as a kill before, however you have stated to me you would rather keep me alive when we played quick mafia. Not on forums. Another good meta point. However, while forgetting that you don't bus, your push o...

Also bruh, why would you not wait for me to post my read list before reveal. Once I posted my reads list, and as I was thinking about Mak's vote on Bessie, I thought about a possibility of you + Mak that I have not considered. Then, all my concerns came together as one in that post. I wanted to sho...

Also bruh, why would you not wait for me to post my read list before reveal.

First of all, no. I will kill you N1 everytime as scum. Playing against you is a headache. (See Sumting Sumting mafia) sumting.png sumting2.png sumting3.png Not sure where you're getting the idea that I would keep you around "for the challenge". You're too rambunctious and unyeetable. Seco...

Seven is scum with Mak Seven has not town telled Day 1, that is established. There has been a certain lack of bravado and scumhunting from Seven. The Mak vote seemed like a pre-mature push due to having no other options at the time. However, Mak seemed to reveal himself to actually be scum, so it s...

Yes. Do you find our death tunnel spiral to be fruitful? Not liking Seven’s choice of metaphor I think he was throwing some shade at me. Huh? I'm leaning on Somi not running such a Gambit as scum. @Ran, I actually think this is towny from Heury. What changed your heury read? See here . Curious as t...

Seven Early gambit is NAI for Seven. I didn’t like how he misinterpreted my confirmation post analysis/suspicion because he has played with me a lot and he knows better. Again, you made a statement but did not provide a reason: @Seven, I don’t like your confirmation post. FoS. This left your reason...

EGW wrote: ↑Mon Apr 15, 2024 10:43 pm Yes, and early.

Then how would I town tell day 1? Additionally, how would you ever read me when I'm wrong?

Also for the future I’m curious what a zen town tell looks like. Is it just yeeting scum?

Tonight

Man I wish y’all would do reverse alphabetical order

Activating ability sometime tomorrow

Mak settling on what's basically my panicky paranoid solve when he's supposed to be a good player counts against, as well as simply wanting to scum read bessie solely off the hammer. I particularly liked Seven's refutation of Mak blaming her for not getting back on EOD. Yeah, that's not a good look...